CommentFic Roundup!
Another vastly successful round of commentfic! Once again, we managed to fill all 142 prompts by the end of the writing period. We have a total of 172 fics from 21 authors. That's pretty good for a week and a half. Congratulations and thanks to everyone who prompted, ficced, read, and feedbacked; I hope you're still alive after all that fun! And a super-special welcome to our new writers who appeared during commentfic - capeofstorm, darkangel0921, and oliver29. Now that we know you can write, you'll have to keep doing so!
If you're afraid you've missed something - or know you've missed quite a bit - never fear! Under the cut, you'll find all of the fics we wrote organized by author and linked with the prompt & prompter listed as well. Be sure to comment on all this fine fic, especially if you prompted it! As always, we are not foolproof gods of code or anything else (though that would be nice), so please let us know if there's a broken link or if we've mistakenly credited something to the wrong person.
alittlebirdy13:
Peter/Brandi, an explanation for the preppy tennis outfits from iheartpants956
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
Mary, Marshall, anyone; Rocky Horror, midnight, on stage from roar526
bithablu:
Mary/Marshall Song:The Bad Touch from darkangel0921
bujyo:
Mary, Marshall, Eleanor, Stan, Bobby, Charlie; Poker night from roar526
MaryMary, anyone; flu, being taken care of from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
capeofstorm:
Marshall, anyone; postcard, stopwatch from 31stcentury
captdeb:
Crossover party! Marshall, Mal (Firefly), anyone else; omg long coats from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); Mann Family Reunion part 1 and part 2 from roar526
darkangel0921:
Eleanor, Faber, the Fliegler, "There's not enough _____ in the world to make me _____." (warning for language) from alittlebirdy13
Mary, Marshall, witness; happy pills, relocate, "looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue" from roar526
Marshall, Charlie, Stan, Bobby; perimeters, Dancing Queen, permanent record from bujyo
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
greenstuff:
O'Connor, Other FBI Asshole, The Devil Went Down to Georgia from lunar_penguin
Stan, Charlie, Stan explains why he became a marshal (Warning: mentions death) from iheartpants956
heirofloki:
Peter, Stan;Pagoda, green chile, links from likelike_love
jms529:
M/M; Walking After You from darkangel0921
AU - Marshall-the-college-professor from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall; retro, favorite musical group, New Kids on the Block from siapom
kittyknighton:
Mary/Marshall, kitten, fleur de lis, crutches from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Brandi/Peter, Mary/Marshall, Jinx; "dinner at the Club", stolen golf cart, 15th green (mild smut) from roar526
Mary, Brandy, Marshall swimming from captdeb
Shirtless, sweaty Marshall/Mary; power tools, vibration, "I can think of a much better use for that" part 1 (ADULT) and part 2 (ALSO ADULT) from roar526
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Faber, Marshall, Brandi, "I hope you know what you're doing" from allierose22
Mary/Marshall, haiku (Limerick edition) from 31stcentury
Temperance Brennan, Mary Shannon, Daddy issues from lunar_penguin
Seeley Booth, Marshall Mann, Pie makes everything better from lunar_penguin
Mary, Marshall; "I was the reason it all ended." from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall, James; Hi, Daddy from vegawriters
Mary/Marshall/Stan/Eleanor, talking about what kind of super powers they would have from iheartpants956
Mary, the exact moment she realizes she is in love with her partner from iheartpants956
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); If Mary had gotten shot during Trojan Hoarst instead of Marshall from allirose22
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); motel, Saturday morning cartoons, "I twought I saw a puddy cat" part 1 and part 2 from roar526
Marshall, Mary, Frost Bite, Heat Exhaustion from pryr_mtns
Mary, Marshall; a moth to a flame, 5 years of my life, enough is enough (WARNING: Angst/Character Death) from greenstuff
Mary, Marshall, Princess Bride, cocktail weenies from captdeb
Mary, Marshall, House, Wilson, "We're not doormats. Are we?" part 1 and part 2 from captdeb
Mary, anyone; pajamajeans, black raspberry ice cream from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); art show, "love at first sight" part 1, part 2, part 3, and part 4 from theinnocentrose
Mary/Marshall: Mary realizes she wants to have Marshall's baby, and they've never even kissed from rj_lupins_kat
Crossover w/Criminal Minds: Marshall, Garcia, + ??; geekiness, secrets, "real women are sexy" from siapom
Mary/Marshall; phobia, "I've never heard of that before" (ADULT) from bujyo
Mary/Brandi, Grandma, smell of Vicks from pryr_mtns
Mary/Marshall; The damage is permanent from vegawriters
Marshall's hurt, and it's Mary's fault (ANGST) from captdeb
Mary/Marshall, guns, rattlesnake, "You wouldn't believe the places I've got dirt." from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Brandi: writing a novel, wicked, hypnotism, 'my sister's partner is totally hot' (ADULT) from rj_lupins_kat
likelike_love:
Brandi, Marshall; rice cooker, pleats from likelike_love
Crossover (Life):Mary, Tidwell; "gel or mouse" from likelike_love
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Stan, who’s the boss from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, haiku from 31stcentury
Mary/Marshall, haiku from 31stcentury
Mary/Marshall, Eleanor: fever, borscht, cosmic payback from bujyo
IPS/Lost Crossover: Mary, Marshall, Charlie; What the hell took us so long? from vegawriters
Where Mary sees the life that could have been had James Shannon not left (with or without Marshall) from caiasm
ADULT: Mary, Marshall; broken zipper, "oh, hell" part one, part two, and part three from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall, ArcAttack, Star Wars, 'Ok, now say that in English." from darkangel0921
Marshall, Faber, submitted video, revenge from darkangel0921
Marshall, any witness, "Gee, Officer Krupke" from lunar_penguin
West Wing Crossover: Marshall/Ainsley; I still don't understand you from vegawriters
Mary, Tasha, Brandi; study buddies, discounts, Gilligan's Island reruns from bujyo
Marshall, Mary; NASA's astronomy picture of the day from vegawriters
lunar_penguin:
Marshall: moving on, Haunting Me by Stabbing Westward (WARNING for angst/major character death) from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, moonless night, gunpowder from alittlebirdy13
ADULT! Mary/Marshall; Next Go Round by Nickelback from siapom
Brandi, Marshall; hobo platter from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall, anyone else?; Firefly marathon, bickering from siapom
Mary/Marshall; Night off, Fortune Cookies, Stories from siapom
AU (your choice of setting) Mary/Marshall; Alexander Rybak's Fairytale from siapom
Anyone; Shakespeare, limericks (warning for langage/suggestion) from pipisafoat
Marshall, Faber, Slap Bet, "wait for it...." from greenstuff
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 1 and part 2 from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall, Eleanor; Stan: The Musical from oliver29
Mary, Marshall, Peter/Brandi; a night on the town, musical theater from siapom
Mary, Marshall, Stan Rubble Without Cause- What if Marshall Got Trapped When Running In To Help from jms529 [part 1 of 3; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 2 and part 3 from kittyknighton [parts 2-3 of 3; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
oliver29:
Mary/Marshall, a bet, hippos, Betty White from oliver29
papillongirl:
Mary/Marshall; wintercoats from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall; First Day of My Life by Bright Eyes (mentions of character death) from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); The Bees by Belly from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall, Stan Rubbble With A Cause - what if Marshall got trapped when running in to help part one and part two from jms529
Any IPS Pairing; Love Will Keep Us Alive by the Eagles, sunset/sunrise, blanket from siapom
AU Mary, Marshall - Marshall is indifferent to Mary's affections, river rocks, "enough already" from siapom
Mary, Marshall; pes planus, Romulus from 31stcentury
Stan, Nicole from the Pilot; "What exactly do you mean by 'creepy'?" from likelike_love
Mary; glasses, If It's Not Love by Rhett Miller from likelike_love
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
pipisafoat:
Crossover - Psych: Mary, Shawn; pineapple butt lotion, "You’re really getting on my nerves" from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall, Stan, Eleanor; office, clown costume, coconut cream pie from roar526
O'Connor, Other FBI Asshole, The Devil Went Down to Georgia from lunar_penguin
Mary/Marshall, beer, bushtit, blue-footed booby from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Marshall, the power goes out from iheartpants956
Crossover: Chase; Annie, Mary; fourth wall from darkangel0921
Mary, Tripp and his siblings, college from caiasm
Mary, Marshall; fireworks, escalating sexual innuendos from likelike_love
Mary, Brandi; class photos, clarinet, steamer trunk from likelike_love
Marshall, Peter, Brandi; LiveJournal, flist, featured community from siapom
Marshall, Mary, Anyone else, Drunken doodles, cheetos from lunar_penguin
M/M, thai food, peanut sauce, "is it hot in here?" from strwbrygrl77
Stan/Eleanor, Mary/Marshall, bowling, "turkey", "Do you need help with your ball?" from strwbrygrl77
Mary, Marshall; caffeine drip, cover me, "Nothing like the smell of coffee and gunpowder in the morning" from roar526
Marshall, Mary, ??; Back to the Future, all nighter, every time they ___ from siapom
Marshall/Mary, 10 Year Night from pipisafoat
Shannon Women, Marshall, America's Funniest Home Videos from darkangel0921
Marshall/Mary, Peter/Brandi, Faber/Jinx, Motorboating from darkangel0921
chico/squish; hamburglar from 31stcentury
Crossover-Covert Affairs Shirtless!Marshall, Shirtless!Auggie, Mary, Annie "I don't even want to know." from darkangel0921
Marshall, Mary; Marshall's garden, a hoe from likelike_love
Jinx, Eleanor; riding crop, birthday cake (AU, angst, character death) from likelike_love
Mary, Marshal (or M/M), Bobby; picnic, sack races, "let the girls out" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); getting stood up, valid excuse from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall; Iris, teenage love from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall, Charlie, Theresa; Never Have I Ever from allirose22
Mary/Mia Cusato - "Would you rather?"" from pryr_mtns
Marshall, Any: "I was built for speed"&"I spend a lot of time in bed but baby I don't like to sleep" (ADULT/SLASH; crossover with X-Files) from rj_lupins_kat
Marshall, Stan; the pen cozy, "this is war" from roar526 [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Marshall/Stan Stan's 45th Birthday and he thinks everyone has forgotten from papillongirl [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Mary, Marshall or M/M; Materia Primoris from darkangel0921 [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary/Marshall Song:Teotihuacan from darkangel0921 [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Mary, anyone; pajamajeans, black raspberry ice cream from likelike_love [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Younger Mary, Older-teen Brandi; jailbait, boyfriend-stealing, sibling rivalry from kittyknighton [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Marshall/Mary, driving in England, candy Valentine's Hearts from lunar_penguin [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary/Marshall; a proposal, an answer, "you amaze me" from bujyo [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
pryr_mtns:
Marshall, Pa Mann, golf, sirens from captdeb
rj_lupins_kat:
Mary/Marshall; gazebo, three weeks old, "something you can't give me" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
roar526:
Eleanor, Faber, the Fliegler, "There's not enough ... in the world to make me..." from alittlebirdy13
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Marshall, Peter/Brandi, mini-golf, water hazard (ADULT) from alittlebirdy13
Eleanor, Faber; chat, snort, "oops" from siapom
Mary/Marshall; gazebo, three weeks old, "something you can't give me" (ANGSTY) from bujyo
Mary/Marshall; The damage is permanent from vegawriters
siapom:
Mary/Marshall, pants, rubber duck, pineapple pizza from iheartpants956
Mary, Marshall, Stan, Eleanor; office, clown costume, coconut cream pie from roar526
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 1 and part 2 from kittyknighton
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
Aunt Rita, tequila shots, an unexpected visitor part 1 and part 2 from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Brandi: writing a novel, wicked, hypnotism, 'my sister's partner is totally hot' from rj_lupins_kat
vegawriters:
Mary/Marshall; winter coats from likelike_love
Peter, Stan;Pagoda, green chile, links from likelike_love
Mary; Untouchable Face by Ani DiFranco (Warning: Adult Language) from likelike_love
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Mary/Marshall, pants, rubber duck, pineapple pizza from iheartpants956
Marshall, anyone; postcard, stopwatch part 1 and part 2 from 31stcentury
Jinx/James - the way we were from greenstuff
(Uh, oh ... Adult!) Marshall, Mary, Peter, Brandi; board game, pluot from 31stcentury
Marshall Owies, Barbecue, Peter from captdeb
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Jinx; the better part of valor from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); stuck in elevator, "that wasn't the button I was talking about" (ADULT) from roar526
Mary, the exact moment she realizes she is in love with her partner (Mild Adult Content) from iheartpants956
Mary/Marshall; Night off, Fortune Cookies, Stories from siapom
Marshall, anyone; leaking air mattress (some adultness!) from likelike_love
Marshall; Japanese, cardigan sweater from likelike_love
Choose 3 or more of the following: Mary, Marshall, Eleanor, Peter, Bobby D; bowling from likelike_love
Marshall, Mary, Anyone else, Drunken doodles, cheetos from lunar_penguin
Mary, Marshall, witness; happy pills, relocate, "looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue" from roar526
Any characters; prostitute, snag, melt from roar526
Faber, FBI office in Denver, Marshall's revenge from oliver29
Jinx, Marshall, Brandi; waiting room, Matisse, "is that normal?" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall; who was the idiot who scheduled six meetings today? from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall; a moth to a flame, 5 years of my life, enough is enough from greenstuff
Daddy!Mann/Mama!Mann; how they met from rainbowwizard1
Mary/Marshall; roadtrip, awkward sleep-talking from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
Crossover - Law and Order SVU: Mary/Olivia; college roommates, "I'll try anything once" from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall (or M/M), Mark; 8 thousand dollars, idiot, adoption part 1, part2, and part 3 from bujyo
ostensible group effort:
Mary, Marshall, Staples/HEB, "Wow! That's a low price!"/"Wow! That's a high price!" from darkangel0921, written by pipisafoat, likelike_love, papillongirl, and 31stcentury (via mind powers)
A giant round of thanks to likelike_love for helping me compile this list (read: doing most of the work) and also to 31stcentury and papillongirl for checking behind us, pointing out the obvious, and generally being the best moral support we could ask for.
Thanks again to everyone for playing, and don't worry - I'm sure this will happen again. Sometime. Eventually. But not yet. We all need a break to refresh our fic-writing minds first!
If you're afraid you've missed something - or know you've missed quite a bit - never fear! Under the cut, you'll find all of the fics we wrote organized by author and linked with the prompt & prompter listed as well. Be sure to comment on all this fine fic, especially if you prompted it! As always, we are not foolproof gods of code or anything else (though that would be nice), so please let us know if there's a broken link or if we've mistakenly credited something to the wrong person.
alittlebirdy13:
Peter/Brandi, an explanation for the preppy tennis outfits from iheartpants956
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
Mary, Marshall, anyone; Rocky Horror, midnight, on stage from roar526
bithablu:
Mary/Marshall Song:The Bad Touch from darkangel0921
bujyo:
Mary, Marshall, Eleanor, Stan, Bobby, Charlie; Poker night from roar526
MaryMary, anyone; flu, being taken care of from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
capeofstorm:
Marshall, anyone; postcard, stopwatch from 31stcentury
captdeb:
Crossover party! Marshall, Mal (Firefly), anyone else; omg long coats from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); Mann Family Reunion part 1 and part 2 from roar526
darkangel0921:
Eleanor, Faber, the Fliegler, "There's not enough _____ in the world to make me _____." (warning for language) from alittlebirdy13
Mary, Marshall, witness; happy pills, relocate, "looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue" from roar526
Marshall, Charlie, Stan, Bobby; perimeters, Dancing Queen, permanent record from bujyo
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
greenstuff:
O'Connor, Other FBI Asshole, The Devil Went Down to Georgia from lunar_penguin
Stan, Charlie, Stan explains why he became a marshal (Warning: mentions death) from iheartpants956
heirofloki:
Peter, Stan;Pagoda, green chile, links from likelike_love
jms529:
M/M; Walking After You from darkangel0921
AU - Marshall-the-college-professor from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall; retro, favorite musical group, New Kids on the Block from siapom
kittyknighton:
Mary/Marshall, kitten, fleur de lis, crutches from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Brandi/Peter, Mary/Marshall, Jinx; "dinner at the Club", stolen golf cart, 15th green (mild smut) from roar526
Mary, Brandy, Marshall swimming from captdeb
Shirtless, sweaty Marshall/Mary; power tools, vibration, "I can think of a much better use for that" part 1 (ADULT) and part 2 (ALSO ADULT) from roar526
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Faber, Marshall, Brandi, "I hope you know what you're doing" from allierose22
Mary/Marshall, haiku (Limerick edition) from 31stcentury
Temperance Brennan, Mary Shannon, Daddy issues from lunar_penguin
Seeley Booth, Marshall Mann, Pie makes everything better from lunar_penguin
Mary, Marshall; "I was the reason it all ended." from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall, James; Hi, Daddy from vegawriters
Mary/Marshall/Stan/Eleanor, talking about what kind of super powers they would have from iheartpants956
Mary, the exact moment she realizes she is in love with her partner from iheartpants956
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); If Mary had gotten shot during Trojan Hoarst instead of Marshall from allirose22
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); motel, Saturday morning cartoons, "I twought I saw a puddy cat" part 1 and part 2 from roar526
Marshall, Mary, Frost Bite, Heat Exhaustion from pryr_mtns
Mary, Marshall; a moth to a flame, 5 years of my life, enough is enough (WARNING: Angst/Character Death) from greenstuff
Mary, Marshall, Princess Bride, cocktail weenies from captdeb
Mary, Marshall, House, Wilson, "We're not doormats. Are we?" part 1 and part 2 from captdeb
Mary, anyone; pajamajeans, black raspberry ice cream from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); art show, "love at first sight" part 1, part 2, part 3, and part 4 from theinnocentrose
Mary/Marshall: Mary realizes she wants to have Marshall's baby, and they've never even kissed from rj_lupins_kat
Crossover w/Criminal Minds: Marshall, Garcia, + ??; geekiness, secrets, "real women are sexy" from siapom
Mary/Marshall; phobia, "I've never heard of that before" (ADULT) from bujyo
Mary/Brandi, Grandma, smell of Vicks from pryr_mtns
Mary/Marshall; The damage is permanent from vegawriters
Marshall's hurt, and it's Mary's fault (ANGST) from captdeb
Mary/Marshall, guns, rattlesnake, "You wouldn't believe the places I've got dirt." from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Brandi: writing a novel, wicked, hypnotism, 'my sister's partner is totally hot' (ADULT) from rj_lupins_kat
likelike_love:
Brandi, Marshall; rice cooker, pleats from likelike_love
Crossover (Life):Mary, Tidwell; "gel or mouse" from likelike_love
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Stan, who’s the boss from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, haiku from 31stcentury
Mary/Marshall, haiku from 31stcentury
Mary/Marshall, Eleanor: fever, borscht, cosmic payback from bujyo
IPS/Lost Crossover: Mary, Marshall, Charlie; What the hell took us so long? from vegawriters
Where Mary sees the life that could have been had James Shannon not left (with or without Marshall) from caiasm
ADULT: Mary, Marshall; broken zipper, "oh, hell" part one, part two, and part three from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall, ArcAttack, Star Wars, 'Ok, now say that in English." from darkangel0921
Marshall, Faber, submitted video, revenge from darkangel0921
Marshall, any witness, "Gee, Officer Krupke" from lunar_penguin
West Wing Crossover: Marshall/Ainsley; I still don't understand you from vegawriters
Mary, Tasha, Brandi; study buddies, discounts, Gilligan's Island reruns from bujyo
Marshall, Mary; NASA's astronomy picture of the day from vegawriters
lunar_penguin:
Marshall: moving on, Haunting Me by Stabbing Westward (WARNING for angst/major character death) from greenstuff
Mary/Marshall, moonless night, gunpowder from alittlebirdy13
ADULT! Mary/Marshall; Next Go Round by Nickelback from siapom
Brandi, Marshall; hobo platter from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall, anyone else?; Firefly marathon, bickering from siapom
Mary/Marshall; Night off, Fortune Cookies, Stories from siapom
AU (your choice of setting) Mary/Marshall; Alexander Rybak's Fairytale from siapom
Anyone; Shakespeare, limericks (warning for langage/suggestion) from pipisafoat
Marshall, Faber, Slap Bet, "wait for it...." from greenstuff
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 1 and part 2 from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall, Eleanor; Stan: The Musical from oliver29
Mary, Marshall, Peter/Brandi; a night on the town, musical theater from siapom
Mary, Marshall, Stan Rubble Without Cause- What if Marshall Got Trapped When Running In To Help from jms529 [part 1 of 3; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 2 and part 3 from kittyknighton [parts 2-3 of 3; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
oliver29:
Mary/Marshall, a bet, hippos, Betty White from oliver29
papillongirl:
Mary/Marshall; wintercoats from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall; First Day of My Life by Bright Eyes (mentions of character death) from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); The Bees by Belly from likelike_love
Mary, Marshall, Stan Rubbble With A Cause - what if Marshall got trapped when running in to help part one and part two from jms529
Any IPS Pairing; Love Will Keep Us Alive by the Eagles, sunset/sunrise, blanket from siapom
AU Mary, Marshall - Marshall is indifferent to Mary's affections, river rocks, "enough already" from siapom
Mary, Marshall; pes planus, Romulus from 31stcentury
Stan, Nicole from the Pilot; "What exactly do you mean by 'creepy'?" from likelike_love
Mary; glasses, If It's Not Love by Rhett Miller from likelike_love
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
pipisafoat:
Crossover - Psych: Mary, Shawn; pineapple butt lotion, "You’re really getting on my nerves" from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall, Stan, Eleanor; office, clown costume, coconut cream pie from roar526
O'Connor, Other FBI Asshole, The Devil Went Down to Georgia from lunar_penguin
Mary/Marshall, beer, bushtit, blue-footed booby from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Marshall, the power goes out from iheartpants956
Crossover: Chase; Annie, Mary; fourth wall from darkangel0921
Mary, Tripp and his siblings, college from caiasm
Mary, Marshall; fireworks, escalating sexual innuendos from likelike_love
Mary, Brandi; class photos, clarinet, steamer trunk from likelike_love
Marshall, Peter, Brandi; LiveJournal, flist, featured community from siapom
Marshall, Mary, Anyone else, Drunken doodles, cheetos from lunar_penguin
M/M, thai food, peanut sauce, "is it hot in here?" from strwbrygrl77
Stan/Eleanor, Mary/Marshall, bowling, "turkey", "Do you need help with your ball?" from strwbrygrl77
Mary, Marshall; caffeine drip, cover me, "Nothing like the smell of coffee and gunpowder in the morning" from roar526
Marshall, Mary, ??; Back to the Future, all nighter, every time they ___ from siapom
Marshall/Mary, 10 Year Night from pipisafoat
Shannon Women, Marshall, America's Funniest Home Videos from darkangel0921
Marshall/Mary, Peter/Brandi, Faber/Jinx, Motorboating from darkangel0921
chico/squish; hamburglar from 31stcentury
Crossover-Covert Affairs Shirtless!Marshall, Shirtless!Auggie, Mary, Annie "I don't even want to know." from darkangel0921
Marshall, Mary; Marshall's garden, a hoe from likelike_love
Jinx, Eleanor; riding crop, birthday cake (AU, angst, character death) from likelike_love
Mary, Marshal (or M/M), Bobby; picnic, sack races, "let the girls out" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); getting stood up, valid excuse from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall; Iris, teenage love from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall, Charlie, Theresa; Never Have I Ever from allirose22
Mary/Mia Cusato - "Would you rather?"" from pryr_mtns
Marshall, Any: "I was built for speed"&"I spend a lot of time in bed but baby I don't like to sleep" (ADULT/SLASH; crossover with X-Files) from rj_lupins_kat
Marshall, Stan; the pen cozy, "this is war" from roar526 [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Marshall/Stan Stan's 45th Birthday and he thinks everyone has forgotten from papillongirl [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Mary, Marshall or M/M; Materia Primoris from darkangel0921 [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary/Marshall Song:Teotihuacan from darkangel0921 [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Mary, anyone; pajamajeans, black raspberry ice cream from likelike_love [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Younger Mary, Older-teen Brandi; jailbait, boyfriend-stealing, sibling rivalry from kittyknighton [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
Marshall/Mary, driving in England, candy Valentine's Hearts from lunar_penguin [part 1 of 2; continued in the next prompt in this list]
++ Mary/Marshall; a proposal, an answer, "you amaze me" from bujyo [part 2 of 2; continued from the previous prompt in this list]
pryr_mtns:
Marshall, Pa Mann, golf, sirens from captdeb
rj_lupins_kat:
Mary/Marshall; gazebo, three weeks old, "something you can't give me" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
roar526:
Eleanor, Faber, the Fliegler, "There's not enough ... in the world to make me..." from alittlebirdy13
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Mary/Marshall, Peter/Brandi, mini-golf, water hazard (ADULT) from alittlebirdy13
Eleanor, Faber; chat, snort, "oops" from siapom
Mary/Marshall; gazebo, three weeks old, "something you can't give me" (ANGSTY) from bujyo
Mary/Marshall; The damage is permanent from vegawriters
siapom:
Mary/Marshall, pants, rubber duck, pineapple pizza from iheartpants956
Mary, Marshall, Stan, Eleanor; office, clown costume, coconut cream pie from roar526
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter part 1 and part 2 from kittyknighton
Marshall, Mary, trivia about your hometown from 31stcentury
Aunt Rita, tequila shots, an unexpected visitor part 1 and part 2 from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Brandi: writing a novel, wicked, hypnotism, 'my sister's partner is totally hot' from rj_lupins_kat
vegawriters:
Mary/Marshall; winter coats from likelike_love
Peter, Stan;Pagoda, green chile, links from likelike_love
Mary; Untouchable Face by Ani DiFranco (Warning: Adult Language) from likelike_love
Mary/Marshall, Marshall has a bad day from iheartpants956
Mary/Marshall, pants, rubber duck, pineapple pizza from iheartpants956
Marshall, anyone; postcard, stopwatch part 1 and part 2 from 31stcentury
Jinx/James - the way we were from greenstuff
(Uh, oh ... Adult!) Marshall, Mary, Peter, Brandi; board game, pluot from 31stcentury
Marshall Owies, Barbecue, Peter from captdeb
don't-f**k-with-me!Marshall/Mary, nosebleed, Kevlar from alittlebirdy13
Stan, Jinx; the better part of valor from pipisafoat
Mary, Marshall (or M/M); stuck in elevator, "that wasn't the button I was talking about" (ADULT) from roar526
Mary, the exact moment she realizes she is in love with her partner (Mild Adult Content) from iheartpants956
Mary/Marshall; Night off, Fortune Cookies, Stories from siapom
Marshall, anyone; leaking air mattress (some adultness!) from likelike_love
Marshall; Japanese, cardigan sweater from likelike_love
Choose 3 or more of the following: Mary, Marshall, Eleanor, Peter, Bobby D; bowling from likelike_love
Marshall, Mary, Anyone else, Drunken doodles, cheetos from lunar_penguin
Mary, Marshall, witness; happy pills, relocate, "looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue" from roar526
Any characters; prostitute, snag, melt from roar526
Faber, FBI office in Denver, Marshall's revenge from oliver29
Jinx, Marshall, Brandi; waiting room, Matisse, "is that normal?" from bujyo
Mary, Marshall; who was the idiot who scheduled six meetings today? from vegawriters
Mary, Marshall; a moth to a flame, 5 years of my life, enough is enough from greenstuff
Daddy!Mann/Mama!Mann; how they met from rainbowwizard1
Mary/Marshall; roadtrip, awkward sleep-talking from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall; character death, in-case-of-death letter from kittyknighton
Crossover - Law and Order SVU: Mary/Olivia; college roommates, "I'll try anything once" from kittyknighton
Mary, Marshall (or M/M), Mark; 8 thousand dollars, idiot, adoption part 1, part2, and part 3 from bujyo
ostensible group effort:
Mary, Marshall, Staples/HEB, "Wow! That's a low price!"/"Wow! That's a high price!" from darkangel0921, written by pipisafoat, likelike_love, papillongirl, and 31stcentury (via mind powers)
A giant round of thanks to likelike_love for helping me compile this list (read: doing most of the work) and also to 31stcentury and papillongirl for checking behind us, pointing out the obvious, and generally being the best moral support we could ask for.
Thanks again to everyone for playing, and don't worry - I'm sure this will happen again. Sometime. Eventually. But not yet. We all need a break to refresh our fic-writing minds first!