Comments | marauderthesn: New Book 7 information

marauderthesn

New Book 7 information

Sep 13, 2006 14:12

So, according to The JKR Lady, why James gave the Invisibility Cloak to Dumbledore is going to be important.

Poll James's CloakI'm glad she told us this was going to be important; I don't like extra bits of information that are never going to be in the books, but I don't mind finding out that fill-in-the-blank is going to be significant later on. Yay, something new ( Read more... )

dh, fandom news

Comments 18

neville81 September 13 2006, 22:40:45 UTC

He, I love your choices (voted for the one with the knitting pattern, by the way). They are refreshing, after I read some boring theories, like Dumbledore simply finding the cloak in the ruins of Godric's Hollow. As if this were in anyway important or even crucial to the storyline.

deerlike September 14 2006, 00:19:13 UTC

I'm glad she told us this was going to be important; I don't like extra bits of information that are never going to be in the books

Wait, sarcasm? :o

marauderthesn September 14 2006, 12:03:41 UTC

No, seriously. Extra bits of information that aren't ever going to be in the book annoy me, as I think we should get to imagine it for ourselves if it isn't important enough to be in the books themselves. However, this is going to be in the book, so this I don't mind.

marauderthesn September 14 2006, 12:05:26 UTC

Dumbledore just finding the cloak would be, like, *snores...* Besides, we already know James left it with him.

mmebahorel September 14 2006, 01:05:54 UTC

Was going to say something amusing and snarky but new - layout - *drool*.

marauderthesn September 14 2006, 12:04:37 UTC

Thanks. :D I wanted something for a while that would include all of my favorite couples.

lunalovegoddess September 15 2006, 13:51:42 UTC

A) I want your layout. (So, lay me out, matey! Arrrgh!)
B) I'm done with the Snape: good or evil discussion... what about the probability that he is true chaotic neutral? He's totally on one side: his own.
C) It's not much of a mental leap that RAB would stand for Regulus Alphard Black... he's mentioned many times in canon, and we now have the NHoB tapestry to work with. Harry inherited GP from Sirius, which indicates that there is something useful there.
D) I'd rather discuss the implications of Umbridge's actions, because the bitch is still in office without being punished for torturing Harry. She needs her comeuppance.