Ch 10: shipmates

Mar 15, 2008 13:29


This is the chapter where

Read more... )

m&c : ch 10, master and commander, shipmates

Leave a comment

Comments 56

mylodon March 15 2008, 12:55:46 UTC
So sad - that whole bit I can see so clearly in my mind. In fact i think the battle is the most vivid of all POB's.

Reply

sharpiefan March 15 2008, 13:11:47 UTC
I had the boarding of Acheron in my mind when reading the battle scene.

As you say, very vivid.

Reply

mylodon March 15 2008, 13:40:24 UTC
Oh indeed - that film is more M and C than Far Side...

Reply

tootsiemuppet March 18 2008, 13:43:31 UTC
Yep, you can see why Weir picked it.

Reply


sharpiefan March 15 2008, 13:18:50 UTC
Guess what! I actually have an icon for the Marines firing their volley at Cacafuego! *uses it*

*huggles Marine*

Reply

esteven March 15 2008, 16:22:06 UTC
They're really doing well. :D

Reply


mmebahorel March 15 2008, 15:31:15 UTC
I just want to say: *sob*

My first time through, that line just killed me - the shock of it, because I had loved Dillon so. Every subsequent time, I know it's coming, but "the great wound in his heart" makes me cry every single time - it's a little obvious, I find, the imagery as metaphor, but it doesn't make it any the less true. And I usually manage to forget Ellis gets the number of his mess, too, because I'm so fixated on Dillon, that that hurts all over again every time as well.

Reply

esteven March 15 2008, 16:27:11 UTC
It is a poignant scene, made all the more so because O'Brian -usually so eloquent in his sentences- is short and cutting. No embroidery, just the naked scene.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

esteven March 16 2008, 07:59:47 UTC
It seems nearly inevitable that Dillon would throw himself into any fight, he is too high strung and too desperate and has probably lost his sense of perspective there. I guess that death may have been preferable to him

Reply


esteven March 15 2008, 16:12:33 UTC
And just when the dear is at her parents with hardly an access to the net.

Reply

tootsiemuppet March 18 2008, 13:47:22 UTC
She'll come.

Reply

esteven March 18 2008, 16:45:35 UTC
I have no doubt of that.
*sniggers*
*has mind like a 13-year old*

Reply

tootsiemuppet March 18 2008, 17:41:44 UTC
Hah, you're horrible.

Reply


The master's appreciation society. :D esteven March 15 2008, 16:45:47 UTC
So he returns angry words with kindness. :D But then, we all know that Stephen and nauticalia do not go together.
'Why, sir, you would have to speak more hasty by half to put me out,' said the master, who was aware of Stephen's liking for him and who valued it highly.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

Re: The master's appreciation society. :D esteven March 16 2008, 07:28:00 UTC
I love your icon. :D

They know that he will do his best for them when they are injured. He is also understanding of their quirks and little vices and does not cast any moral judgement on them.

Reply

Re: The master's appreciation society. :D sidlj March 16 2008, 17:00:30 UTC
It's nice that Mr. Marshall isn't jealous of Stephen's particular friendship with Jack. He was jealous of Dillon for a while there, but not Stephen, apparently.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up