This is a Doctor Who post.

[madlori]

As some of you know, I was a classic Whovian Back in the Day. I wrote fanfic about Seven, my first fanfics ever. I watched all the episodes, even the telesnap reconstructions. I went to conventions. I have pictures of myself with three different Doctors (Five, Six and Seven) and various companions. I have autographs. I was in a club.That kind

Comments

[pie_is_good]

I'd really suggest starting from the beginning of S5 to really get an opinion on Matt Smith. After all, Vincent and the Doctor isn't really that big of a DW episode. There is, as you pointed out, hardly a plot, and while the episode is generally sort of awesome, it didn't do much for the characters or the plot. It's just sort of...pretty and awesome on its own. I really don't think you'd get a good perception of Eleven from that episode alone.

[aeryn42]

Just as an aside-- I cry at like, every Dr. Who episode. I just started watching the new series (from the 9th Doctor) and we're in season 3, which I love (though seemingly getting a little darker than 1 & 2?). But I seriously cry big sobby tears after almost every episode.

[anonamys]

The funny thing is that I find myself getting used to the new doctor and accepting him (well, for the first two of the new series - not sure if I'll adjust to Matt Smith), but find that no companion is living up to Rose. Actually, I kind of like Amy (not even because of her name), but all the other companions have been either annoying or forgettable to me.

[madlori]

It looked like an Alien Chicken. That is all. :-)

[shing_]

I'm kinda an anomaly in the Doctor Who fandom as Nine did nothing for me, I HATED Rose with a passion, loved Martha as much as fandom hated her and pretty much love Eleven to bits. I'm of the mind that you like who like. I have a friend who declared she didn't like Eleven. I called her crazy and then we moved on :)