Comments | madamotaku: HAPPIES. MAJOR HAPPIES.

madamotaku

HAPPIES. MAJOR HAPPIES.

May 31, 2008 17:27

Comments 13

fallen_iceangel June 1 2008, 02:36:04 UTC

I hate most female characters in general (in every fandom) with few exceptions... so my opinion may be considered biased. ^^U

I think I'll leave it at that so I don't because too much of a killjoy...

Other than that, I loved the eppy. :D

madamotaku June 1 2008, 03:07:53 UTC

Heh, so if River had been exactly the same but male, would you have liked him?

fallen_iceangel June 1 2008, 12:17:02 UTC

We already have a Jack.

And I don't think so. There are times when Jack's too... Jack for me.

madamotaku June 1 2008, 16:20:39 UTC

I don't see the Jack comparison myself (she's not that big a slut for one thing) but we all see things in our own way. Several people liked Jenny, for instance, and I didn't understand that at all, other than the fact that she's cute as a button.

Thread 5

Sorry to spoil, but... percyprune June 1 2008, 07:39:48 UTC

When they say 'saved' connect the dots to the remark about the biggest hard drive in the universe...

Re: Sorry to spoil, but... madamotaku June 1 2008, 07:46:43 UTC

Yeah, that's what I was thinking as well. Plus, the audio commentary for this ep pretty much gives the whole thing away.

Re: Sorry to spoil, but... gillyp June 1 2008, 11:42:59 UTC

I'm SO glad I decided not to listen yet, then. Man...

An entire script based on the idea of the evilness of SPOILARZ gillyp June 1 2008, 11:41:50 UTC

YES!!! That was my favourite bit too - that and the delightfully hand-doodled TARDIS cover. I can't help feeling the fact she's totin' a spoilery BOOK (in a possibly not-entirely real Library???) is highly significant.

I loved River but can't help feeling there's a whole lot more to her and her story -and her history with the Doc than seems to be the case.

And her super-silly name has to be deeply significant (or else there's just no excuse for it at all *G*)

Re: An entire script based on the idea of the evilness of SPOILARZ madamotaku June 1 2008, 16:44:55 UTC

Yeah. I think "River Song" is a reference to what the Ood said to the Doctor in Planet of the Ood. But it's still a bit much.

I NEED a Tardis journal! I love how the Doctor couldn't resist trying to look at it even though he had to know that SPOILARZ were inside.

Re: The book thing has got me thinking rather a lot. gillyp June 1 2008, 17:01:05 UTC

Like, what's with the weird ISBN bar-code affair on the kid - Cal's - wall?

I'm so looking forward to seeing where they go with this.

Re: The book thing has got me thinking rather a lot. madamotaku June 2 2008, 01:07:30 UTC

Ohhh, so SHE'S Cal? I didn't make that connection. Heh, I was trying to figure out what her wall drawings meant. There were the ones that looked like Rose in glasses and a wolf, but there was also a brunette woman and a cat, I think.

Thread 5