When I Want Time Travel

[mabfan]

There's a photo making the rounds again on Facebook of a protestor holding up a sign that reads, "What Do We Want? Time Travel! When Do We Want It? It's Irrelevant!" Invariably, people share it with me, and I do appreciate it a lot (even if one of the Facebook pages that it comes from has a name with an obscenity in it

Comments

[serge_lj]

"...where are all the time travelers?..."

They all wind up on the Titanic and drown.

[rivkaesque]

What concerns me is the alternate universe/paradox issues. Let's assume for a moment that creating a paradox through time travel won't result in a time loop or a universe-ending cataclysm. If one makes a change to the past and returns to a different future, doesn't that indicate that pre-destination is real? That would tend to sap my morale.
If one returns to a different future, how can one be certain that it's the actual timeline one has altered, given that one has either generated a paradox (changes made based on a history that never existed which would have meant not making those changes which would have meant that the history did exist etc.) or one has generated a new alternate universe, and all the alternates of that alternate - how can one be certain that the new one is even remotely related to the one from which one came?

[seborn]

If one makes a change to the past and returns to a different future, doesn't that indicate that pre-destination is real? That would tend to sap my morale.

huh? That sounds like it indicates that causality is real.

I'm in future-me's past right now, after all. If no matter who I talked to, what I read, what job I took, how I raised my kid, it would put us all in exactly the same spot in ten years, that would be unreasonable, pretty futile, and contrary to how I expect the universe to work. If I (or somebody else) travelled in time and tweaked my life, I'd expect my life to behave as if it had been tweaked.

[rivkaesque]

But that would indicate that you (or someone else) would necessarily make the decision to travel into the past to make that tweak - that you had no real choice in the matter, it was just how the universe was going to work.

[ericjamesstone]

> One of the standard questions that gets asked about
> time travel is, "If time travel is possible, where
> are all the time travelers?"

Yes, when Stephen Hawking made that argument, I realized I was smarter than Stephen Hawking (on that point, at least.)

[violetcheetah]

Or perhaps they created time travel decades ago, and have since gone back to the origins to hide that creation, and in the timeline we are in they were successful in covering their tracks.

[framlingem]

The other possibility, which is either encouraging or discouraging, is that the last hundred years are considered to be a really boring part of history that nobody actually wants to visit. Sort of like living in a small town in Nebraska (note: have never actually been to Nebraska. For all I know its small towns are fascinating. This is the stereotyped view of small towns in Nebraska belonging to a Canadian) and going "if tourists are real, where are they?"

We could also posit that this is the most well-recorded time in history to-date. From an archaeological standpoint, you'd want to go back in time to before mass-communication was invented, or to before writing was invented. If time-travel turns out to be very expensive, it seems like that would be the best use of it.

Alternately, time-travellers are everywhere, but have exceedingly good camouflage and, at worst, come off as a bit eccentric.

[teddywolf]

You forget the alternative: that we are living in a time of some of the most powerful social upheavals ever, and that smart time travelers would rather take a nap.

Of course, there's one thing that everybody else seems to be forgetting, especially for a bunch of science fiction fans and authors. Namely, we're assuming humans are the ones who will make the first time machine and that it's not been made yet. Leaving aside the killer robots theory (which has been done to death in Terminator movies), what about more evolved animals, such as superintelligent octopi? Or non-Earth creatures? Or (dare I say it?) faeries. Why else would you enter their hill for a night and show up again the next morning to find out it's 20 years later?