Comments | m_mcgregor: Fic: I Am What I Am (67/67)

m_mcgregor

Fic: I Am What I Am (67/67)

Jul 22, 2007 00:13

Comments 10

katekat1010 October 29 2007, 05:47:40 UTC

This has been one of the most enthralling trips I've ever taken in five years reading of every Buffy fanfic I could get my hands on. Thank you. I was completely and utterly immersed in this world from the moment I finished the first paragraph. The concept was intriguing and the way you've developed it was simply fantastic - from Xander's ability to forge weapons, Willow's magical plans, saving both Kendra and Jonathon, to Ethan's appearance as a (sort of) force for good. It's obvious that you not only love these characters, but you've thought about them and in some way or another dreamed their dreams. I'm staggered, awed, and incredibly happy to have followed draconin's rec (from buffyversetop5) and found this wonderful world you've created. Again, thank you, very much.

m_mcgregor October 29 2007, 06:11:45 UTC

Thanks right back at you, it's always great to know when someone's enjoyed something I've written, and since this is the story I am probably most proud of out of anything I've ever written, it's an added kind of thrill when people like it.

brindel November 3 2007, 00:35:03 UTC

*deep shuddery breath*

Whoo. I mean, Damn! What a ride.

I laughed, I sobbed, I stayed up til FOUR FREAKIN' AM just to finish the thing!

*Biggest Stupid-Happy Grin EVAR*

m_mcgregor November 4 2007, 15:25:41 UTC

Hey, thanks a lot, it's great to know how much you enjoyed it.

anonymous March 27 2008, 10:53:49 UTC

Wow.

I found this listed on the rec section of tvtropes, and figured, what the heck, I haven't read any fanfic in a while. And I just kept reading and reading and reading.

Excellent fic, proto-Faith was very interesting, and every time I thought you were going to go down a well worn route of destiny being unstoppable, you managed to sneak one past me. (especially with the Jenny and Giles bit which so closely mimicked how he found her the first time round. That was downright cruel, but brilliant in how you subverted it)

If you ever decide to write more in this particular verse, I'll be here to read it.

anonymous March 27 2008, 10:58:42 UTC

Sorry, forgot, I'm Steven. Don't have a livejournal account and forgot to put in my name :P

Great Story anonymous December 16 2008, 04:46:24 UTC

Great story. I just it spend all weekend reading it. Are you planning a sequel? I REALLY want to know what happens when they go to college and Willow meets Tara. Obviously Oz isn't going anywhere, but Older Willow made it clear that Tara was her soul mate. How is it handled?

There are also so many things that happened in the series that will be different now. Xander can warn Buffy about Prof. Walsh and the Initiative which means no Adam and Riley will be out of the picture. Also, what will happen when Dawn and Glory come into the picture? Will Xander make her a weapon? Can they defeat Glory with the weapons or will something else have to happen? I have so many questions and potential ideas, but I need you to use your amazing imagination and writing skills to make them real. Please do. Either way please respond. my e-mail is robbinsbm@uindy.edu

rocit63 April 1 2009, 02:30:27 UTC

I just finished reading this story for probably the 10th or 12th time and I remembered you had been reposting it somewhere. So tonight I went hunting for it and I thrilled to find your LJ! I love this story thank you so much for writing and sharing it!!

rocit63 April 1 2009, 02:31:28 UTC

Are you going to write a sequel?