Comments | lotr_lims: Round Two: Final Challenge

_allshallfade in lotr_lims

Round Two: Final Challenge - Results

Jan 20, 2007 15:57

( And the Last Icon Maker Standing is... )

Comments 15

pokecharm January 20 2007, 22:08:28 UTC

big ups to erunameundomiel! congrats dear!! I'm so happy for you!!

and with respect to comments, and I can certainly respect how hard it is to run a lims com, but being a participant I have to say that some times the 'lesser' reasons were sometimes spurious at best. I know its hard to police the types of comments people leave, but if people are going to label an icon lesser, then may be something constructive too? just a thought!

_allshallfade January 20 2007, 22:14:12 UTC

I definitely see where you're coming from, because I feel the same way about the comments. It says in the rules of every voting post that people should try to be constructive in their criticism, but as long as the votes aren't personal, I have to count them. It's hard enough to get people to vote without saying "I think" and "I don't like" that to strictly enforce being constructive would be close to impossible, unfortunately.

pokecharm January 20 2007, 22:17:53 UTC

well, its good to know you're aware of it and I know a lot of people avoid voting because they think it'll some how help their chances, which makes no sense to me :p I just wish people would be more honest, the honour system isn't to hard to abide by I think ;)

_allshallfade January 20 2007, 22:19:19 UTC

Do they really? That doesn't make sense at all.

Thread 7

gabsy January 20 2007, 22:32:58 UTC

I just want to congratulate everyone, because some incredibly beautiful icons have been posted, and each voting was usually a pleasure for the eyes!

Anyway, congratulations everyone!

erunameundomiel January 20 2007, 23:08:40 UTC

Well, wow! I'm very surprised. :) Thanks very much. :D

Many congratulations to green_quees for being one of the final two. :)

erunameundomiel January 21 2007, 07:40:01 UTC

Ugh...I suck...I totally didn't realize I spelt green_queen wrong. Dunno how I got that typo.

watchpoint January 20 2007, 23:27:45 UTC

Congratulations to both of you!

(The comment has been removed)

erunameundomiel January 21 2007, 07:47:29 UTC

Eh, it's kind of hard to know what to say in these situations isn't it?

Looking over all your icons, I like the humor you injected into them. :) That's something I find fairly hard to do.

I also think it's interesting to see how much our general style differs. I find it interesting that the last two have contrasting styles. You'd think it would be the opposite.