Comments | lotr_community: November 2015- "Nostalgia" challenge

periantari in lotr_community

November 2015- "Nostalgia" challenge

Nov 27, 2015 23:01

Author: periantari
Title: If He Never
Rating: G
Theme: Nostalgia
Elements: "yesteryear"
Author's Notes: My favorite character, my favorite type of fic length. :)
Summary: Frodo has a moment of despair during the Quest.
Word Count: 300

( Read more... )

challenge: nostalgia, month: 2015 november

Comments 27

silver_trails December 1 2015, 13:45:49 UTC

It really took the joy of life from him, and yet his quest saved the world. That's sad.

periantari December 4 2015, 04:13:28 UTC

I know-- it really did. :( Frodo will never be the same. :hugsFrodo:

engarian December 1 2015, 15:40:09 UTC

There was nothing simple about Frodo's quest, and in the doing of it, all things were scrubbed clean to the quick, including memories. Poor Frodo!

- Erulisse (one L)

periantari December 4 2015, 04:16:08 UTC

Frodo would never be the same after the Quest which is the most heartbreaking part of this story. That is what i feel appealing and obviously the most sad. Poor Frodo indeed! :(

lbilover December 1 2015, 19:25:27 UTC

Such a cruel contrast between Frodo's memories and the reality of the Quest. *hugs Frodo*

periantari December 4 2015, 04:16:34 UTC

:hugs Frodo with you: Thanks for your comment!

grey_wonderer December 1 2015, 20:43:13 UTC

I love this, but you know that. Great title by the way. Frodo's thoughts seem so vivid and so real. His angst comes through very well in this and his concern for not only himself, but for his Shire and his friends. I really enjoyed this.

periantari December 4 2015, 04:17:44 UTC

Thank you, thank you! I am so surprised by the amount of support this got... old fashioned angst never gets old, right? ;) =) I was thinking of writing Sam's POV in this too. :) i'm glad you think his thoughts seem genuine.
Thank you for liking this (again) ! :)