Doomsday...

Jul 08, 2006 20:28

Mmm... well. Meh.

Two spoilers )

who

Leave a comment

Comments 6

madscot July 8 2006, 19:47:33 UTC
Even OH (who has not liked either new Doctor) commented on the snark between them. I found the bit with the 'family' a bit Mills and Boone (not that I have ever read any). Is it as surprise that Thomas Hardy is my favourite author? More realistic endings (though in the case of Jude, just too brutal).

Reply

littlemoose July 8 2006, 19:56:16 UTC
It was a bit too tidy, wasn't it? But it was kind of what was needed - get rid of Rose and you HAVE to get rid of Mickey and Jackie. It could have been a little less mawkish, though.

Reply

madscot July 8 2006, 19:59:01 UTC
I think I would have not made the retching noises if they'd left out the new baby. Rose getting a version of her Dad is just unbelievable to me. He is not her Dad - just someone who looks like him.

Reply

littlemoose July 8 2006, 20:03:11 UTC
That bit rankled, I'll admit... as did Jackie's ready acceptance of him... and he of her, come to think, after all, she's not his dead wife, either.

If you want to hit Rusty with the Clue-By-Four, I'll hold him down :)

Reply


dracothelizard July 9 2006, 00:29:13 UTC
Snarky Dalek was the BEST.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up