Okay, okay, fine.

[lily_handmaiden]

Comments

[yumpacepicante]

Haha it seems like people were after your head for saying Snape was truly evil.

I don't know one way or another (I'm trying to convince myself he isn't), but I'm still fighting the denial of Dumbledore's death so I'll get back to you.

[anonymous]

I came to the same conclusions about Snape not being evil and actually having good intentions in killing Dumbledore. But I'm a lot more excited about that theory now that I have read that other guy's prediction that one of your respondees posted. Because I hadn't gone the extra step to assuming that Snape was reading Dumbledore's mind through legilimens and then the logical conclusions about the facil expressions of Snape and the freak out about being called a coward. Although I did assume that with the facial expression of revulsion (what I considered to be my biggest obstacle to Snape's having good intentions if he did indeed detest Dumbledore) that JKR was using that to fool us like she has done in past books knowing that the reader will draw the same conclusions as Harry, but not necessarily the correct conclusions. Although, I was eager to look for an excuse for Severus to actually be good because he has always been my favorite character and I adore him

[lily_handmaiden]

Hee! I'm so glad to hear your opinion on this. One of the first things I thought after finishing the book was, "Kelly must be freaking. Out."

[eve_wings]

Hey, Erin, how do you make your LJ post your pic along the side? I want to fix my LJ so it does that.