Comments | likethegun_lims: RESULTS - challenge six, round nine

zestyzorra in likethegun_lims

RESULTS - challenge six, round nine

Apr 14, 2013 19:37

Thank you, voters! Unfortunately, we have to say goodbye to two iconmakers this week.

Banner-maker this week is absolutelybatty.

( results for challenge six )

r. 9 challenge six, results, round nine

Comments 12

naive_astronaut April 15 2013, 07:28:51 UTC

thank you so much for mod's choice!
#6 please:) unscreened is ok

zestyzorra April 15 2013, 10:45:21 UTC

:)

Favorite:
- I love the moody coloring and lighting.
- Damn it! I wish I had done this! This was a really difficult cap and you managed it beautifully. You captured the moody feeling with the coloring, and the way it goes from light to dark across his face.

Least Favorite:
- The coloring is uneven and the yellow tint of the top right quadrant makes the subject look jaundiced. The icon would benefit from a more natural skin tone overall.

absolutelybatty April 15 2013, 08:16:19 UTC

Comments for 04, please. Unscreened is tops.

ETA: tried to post my banners, but I don't have access. Would you prefer me to simply send them to one of you to post or wait for access and post them myself?

zestyzorra April 15 2013, 10:44:36 UTC

Oops, sorry about that! You now have posting access so feel free to post them when you get time. :)

Favorite:
- Love the texture work and coloring.
- Oh this is so beautiful, I love everything about it. Gorgeous coloring and contrast.

Least Favorite:
- The bright parts are too bright. It is distracting and unbalanced the icon.

vampire_sessah April 15 2013, 09:51:48 UTC

Thanks so much!
Congrats to the other winners! :)

Can I get the comments for #04 please? Unscreened is fine!

zestyzorra April 15 2013, 10:46:41 UTC

Congrats!

Favorite:
- I really like the crop with the face is half in shadow
- Wonderful crop here, and I love the darker coloring as well. It really adds an emotional punch to the screencap that the other versions don't have.
- Game of shodows and crop are amazing
- Amazing use of the coloring and the shadows to fit the mood of the pic..

Least Favorite:
- Too dark, coloring rather muted.
- Coloring and contrast are a bit flat. I see where your going with the heavy shadowing, but I don't think it works so well with the crop.

light_ofmy_life April 15 2013, 14:29:23 UTC

Thanks for the votes! And congrats to other winners!

May I have comments for #5 please? Unscreened is fine.

zestyzorra April 15 2013, 21:40:10 UTC

Congrats ( ... )

(The comment has been removed)

zestyzorra April 15 2013, 21:40:40 UTC

Thanks for participating! :)

Did you still want your comments?

(The comment has been removed)

zestyzorra April 16 2013, 02:25:15 UTC

Here you go:

Least Favorite:
- Neat coloring, but the icon looks blurry and the texture work makes it look like the image is low quality.
- I love the concept here but the image is just too blurry and pixelated. If there was more detail in Sam's face, I think this icon would be much more successful.
- I like the attempt here, but I feel like I can't clearly see what's going on around Sam and Dean's hands, it's all just a light gray blur.
- The icon looks blurry. There's also a lack of contrast? It results in a lack of depth in the icon.