Round 1 // Challenge 9 Results

Mar 18, 2007 16:24

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is icywind.

Challenge 9 Results )

results, round one, challenge nine

Leave a comment

Comments 40

meivocis March 18 2007, 06:44:25 UTC
13 please, thanks.

Reply

meivocis March 18 2007, 06:46:01 UTC
Oh, and unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

shadowserenity March 18 2007, 06:51:47 UTC
- Love the joining of the two images, the texture backgroud is very nice
- gorgeous use of textures
- [love the color and texturing]
- the texture is overpowering, and it looks like one face chopped in half and put back oddly rather than (I'm assuming) Shep and Rodney.

Early entry this week for CH10 maybe? :)

Reply

meivocis March 18 2007, 06:56:14 UTC
I haven't even checked out the images! Patience my dear child, patience. ;)

Reply


odannygirl7 March 18 2007, 06:46:45 UTC
I *knew* this was the week I should have skipped. This is still the longest I've ever lasted in a LIMS. And 6 neg votes is way better than my usual 11 or so. Unscreened comments please.

Reply

shadowserenity March 18 2007, 06:53:26 UTC
Thank you for participating :).

- The coloring is just too dull and boring.
- The icon is rather blank compared to the rest. I'd make it either completely b/w or use more colors.
- Like the coloring, but John's outlines are weirdly blurry. And the background is sharp, so it doesn't look purposeful.
- John's outline is much too blurry compared to the sharp lines of his facial features; it makes for an odd contrast
- This icon is just so plain. Nothing really jumps out at me.
- The washed-out effect gives it an unfinished look.

Reply


oregonblondie March 18 2007, 06:59:00 UTC
Hoshoot. I was actually heading back over here to see when voting was over. There were so many gorgeous entires this week, and I just took too long to mull it over.

Good job, y'all! Another amazing week.

Reply

shadowserenity March 18 2007, 07:04:59 UTC
Thanks for the support! :D

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

shadowserenity March 18 2007, 07:10:57 UTC
- very creative design; excellent blending; fitting text; it caught my eye immediately.
- Beautiful colouring.
- Nice blending, colours suit images well, and text compliments icon nicely
- Love the rich colors.
- I LOVE IT!!!
- great composition
- love the color scheme! the blending is very nice, and even though everything is almost too perfectly smooth, it's not overdone and giives the icon a very interesting feel. very nice text placement.
- Gorgeous, warm colours and amazing blend.
- nice composition and colouring.
- Lovely blending

Reply


sars March 18 2007, 07:01:35 UTC
Okay, can't believe I'm still here.

#17 please, unscreened :)

Reply

shadowserenity March 18 2007, 07:12:26 UTC
Yup, still here :). Final 20 now.

- The coloring and liney blurs are unattractive
- Ooh, I really like the blurry effect. It really accentuates Rodney.
- I like the 'old photograph' feel this has.
- [the b/w with a touch of red looks epic, and also the cropping is nicely done]

Reply

ninnui March 18 2007, 07:25:13 UTC
I really love the Rodney icon! Is it snagable? <33

Reply

sars March 18 2007, 07:40:10 UTC
Thanks :D

You're completely welcome to the icon.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up