Round 1 // Challenge 9 Results

[shadowserenity]

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is icywind.

Comments

[aoihikari]

yesh! i live on! :P

comments for 12 please? unscreened is fine. :D

[shadowserenity]

- [The text kind of just sticks out]
- [I really like the simplicity of this icon and the slight hint of texturing.]

[ninnui]

Huh, still there! *relieved* May I please have my comments - unscreened is fine :) Thank you.

[shadowserenity]

- Nice coloring and good use of tiny text. Much better than just half a white icon.
- Love the lighting & color
- The white space is really overwhelming and the colouring of her eyes isn't flattering.

[ninnui]

Thanks, that was quick :)

[shadowserenity]

After I post the results, I usually just sit here for an hour surfing around lj and hitting refresh on the recent comments page. After that hour, you guys don't get immediate replies ;).

[estragora]

Yay, thanks so much! 16 please, unscreened is fine :)

[shadowserenity]

You're welcome :).

- Adore the colours and the effect.
- This icon is GORGEOUS.

[amanda_is_wacky]

Oh well, I made it half way, which is good enough for me seeing as my graphics muse is deader than a dodo lately! LOL.

Can I have my comments (for #9) screened please?

[kaaatie]

Could I have the comment for #1 please? Unscreened is fine. Thanks! :)

[shadowserenity]

- Crop and colouring is boring, texture border is distracting
- It's too plain and the brush along the edge doesn't fit.
- nice cropping and placement. the background texture and color are what makes this icon great.
- The whole thing looks kinda bland.