4.13 - Piece Of My Heart Discussion Post

May 02, 2008 08:16

This post is to discuss and review last night's episode more thoroughly in longer, more coherent comments. Please refrain from posting one-liners and keep the "SQUEE", "OMG", and other similar comments to an absolute minimum, and add them to one of our reaction posts instead. If discussing a certain aspect of the episode, please include subject ( Read more... )

season [all]: ep. discussion

Leave a comment

Comments 64

xnikki118x May 2 2008, 06:51:47 UTC
Are they laying the groundwork for Callie and Hahn to become a couple or what?

It seemed like the only reason Callie went to dance with/sleep with Mark again was because she's afraid she's falling for a chick.

Christina is usually a little over-the-top about Hahn, but I thought she was in the right to say Hahn is no longer welcome in her apartment. Hahn treats her like crap for no reason.

Rose: "heavy petting"? Are you in high school? Please DIAF kthx.

Poor Bailey. =(

Reply

xnikki118x May 2 2008, 06:56:33 UTC
Also, the way Addison was talking about Derek, it almost sounds like she's still in love with him. Didn't she say something about if she'd stayed in Seattle she'd still be with him? She also kept referring to him as "my husband". Hm.

Oh, and Ava/Rebecca. I'm wondering if she knowingly lied about the pregnancy or if something is up. ['Something' being her home test was wrong, the labs were wrong, maybe she was pregnant but miscarried on the way to Seattle?]

Reply

lilacmermaid May 2 2008, 11:45:18 UTC
Definitely noticed how Addison called Derek her husband, rather than ex-husband. It makes me sad and I wish she was still on the show.

I'll have to watch the show again, but apart from the weird reaction from Callie when Addison first brought it up, I thought any attraction between Callie/Hahn was entirely on Hahn's side. Maybe it will be something that will get in the way of their friendship? Or they're setting it up for Hahn to be with someone new? Just thinking out loud here...

Reply

annod039 May 2 2008, 10:49:31 UTC
I completely agree with you about the Cristina thing. She can be over the top, but Hahn can be overly bitchy too, and Cristina has every right to say she can't be there anymore. Way to stand up for herself.

And yeah, poor Bailey. If she had to tell Addison, one of very few people she ever opened up to, to go away, just so the pain would stop, it has to be bad...

Reply


sundayxlove May 2 2008, 09:36:40 UTC
i used to be all for alex/ava but now she just irritates me. i'm thinking maybe she lied about the pregnancy. if she didn't then she should have at least waited longer to come running to alex about it.

Reply

xkissablenquiet May 2 2008, 15:40:55 UTC
I was never for them and I wish she would go away. Doesn't she already have a husband and a kid???

Reply

hiddenoffstage May 2 2008, 16:14:56 UTC
But she did finally get him to sit down with her, which might be why she lied since every other attempt at talking to him about what is going on between them has failed. I'm not in support of her lying, but I can see her possible reasoning.

Reply


hibbleton May 2 2008, 10:14:24 UTC
The feminist in me thinks/hopes that Addison telling Meredith to fight for "Derek Christopher Shepherd" is her saying that he might be a fricking idiot, but he's still worth fighting for, as opposed to the alternative -- that Shonda is once again writing that it's all Meredith's fault they're not together.

Reply

annod039 May 2 2008, 10:53:49 UTC
You know, I thought that too, and I would agree with you, but then I read that article someone just posted in from Entertainment Weekly. You have to read all of it, because it's at the very end, but they talk about how Derek has crap he hasn't brought to the table yet, so it isn't just Meredith. So let's hope that Addison isn't placing all the blame on her too.

Reply

lilacmermaid May 2 2008, 11:47:33 UTC
I kind of wondered about that too, because what else is Meredith really supposed to do at this point??

That being said, I think Addison was equally mad at Derek yesterday, it just happens that we ended on an anti-Meredith note. And it's not as though Addison ever loved Meredith to begin with, so it would be easier to be mad at her rather than Derek.

Reply


maigray May 2 2008, 13:16:30 UTC
I thought Addison's diatribes were pretty evenly spread between Meredith and Derek - and I don't think she's blaming either one more than the other. I think she's deeply annoyed that the relationship that ended her marriage hasn't lived up to itself. It's..insulting to her on a personal level.

I didn't like that Meredith called herself a whore. I know it was meant in a humorous way, but..it's not funny. Really.

Reply

ashelia May 2 2008, 18:40:10 UTC
It's very in character though. She has a lot of issues with herself and knows she's extraordinarily sexually loose.

Reply


lastbeautflgirl May 2 2008, 14:10:08 UTC
I absolutely loved that elevator scene at the end! Awkward!

Ava/whatsherface = pseudocyesis? Or she's just being a bitch, which I already think she is. She's annoying and I hope she goes away.

Reply

marilyn_glamor May 2 2008, 15:35:06 UTC
Me too! When Mark walked in, I was dying. Leave it to Grey's to do something like that!

Reply

butterflybangs May 2 2008, 16:02:32 UTC
That elevator scene lacked a good speech. Addison should have jumped all over Derek, Meredith and Rose while in there. Perfect squandered opportunity. *sigh*

Reply


Leave a comment

Up