House/SGA Crossover Fanfic Rant

Sep 21, 2009 00:22

Anybody read fanficrants? This recent rant was about House/Stargate crossovers! What do you think? Have you seen any fic that would match the ranter's complaint? Because I can't recall any.

Leave a comment

Comments 9

nightdog_barks September 21 2009, 04:39:44 UTC
Maybe pwcorgigirl's fic? The one where he diagnoses Ronon?

:-(

ETA: Dangerous Ground

Reply

pwcorgigirl September 21 2009, 11:07:22 UTC
It does sound like mine. Nice to know it only took 15 months for someone to come up with a beef to discuss in the cool kids' locker room.

Reply

deelaundry September 21 2009, 12:16:32 UTC
As I wrote on the post, I think (unless she's read fics I haven't) the ranter is not thinking through the whole issue. House has a deeper understanding of medicine, anatomy, and biology than simply selecting Disease A vs. Parasite B.

Reply

pwcorgigirl September 21 2009, 13:52:20 UTC
Thanks, Dee.

Reply


bironic September 21 2009, 11:51:11 UTC
I just tried to comment with the following but I can't because I'm not a ffr member. If anyone wants to copy and paste for me, that'd be fine. Otherwise, allow me to preach to the choir.

From what I understand, diagnostics is not just about fitting symptoms to known diseases, but can also involve identifying new diseases. The National Institutes of Health has a whole program dedicated to diagnosing rare diseases, more common diseases with unusual presentations, and also diseases that haven't been seen before. I don't see why House wouldn't be able to do the same, be it Earth- or Pegasus-generated, so long as, as deelaundry points out, the story is written believably.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up