I've only seen Luke, Noah and Reid so I haven't seen the rest...I loved the Nuke scene. I was not cool at all with Reid trashing on Noah. I think I might have to watch it again to see what you see.
Whole show was really good. You're gonna enjoy it! :-)
I think with me, this whole thing concerning Noah and his behavior is extremely personal. I've been through what Luke went through with Noah, so Noah's behavior tends to bother me more than it probably should. Also, I'm a self-proclaimed Luke-girl, so my heart always goes with him first.
This is not to say that I don't love Noah. I've just been struggling with him these last few months because of how he's been pushing Luke away and not even realizing how painful that's been for Luke. I personally don't feel like Reid trashed Noah, especially since he was very calm when talking about him, but I can definitely understand how it could be offensive. I mean, Luke was upset by it, too! So it's totally legit that you would get upset with Reid going on and on about Noah. *hugs*
Well, as usual your recaps surpass the actual show :).
I actually like the Reid character...I just don't like him as a romantic interest for Luke *shrug*. He "trashed" Luke to Noah too, so fair play and all. I can see where Luke would gravitate to the interest being shown to him, and I think I can understand Reid's attraction to Luke too. Though, I actually get what Noah was doing in pushing Luke away, at first he was angry and then he was trying to protect himself - and that I totally relate too.
I really dig Carly and Parker's relationship and I really like how she doesn't let him get away with anything. She is a good mom. Faith is so head over heels for Parker, it's almost painful. Nu-Faith isn't my favorite though.
I love Lucinda! As usual, Lily didn't listen to her, but I really liked their scenes and I especially liked her telling nu-Faith to be nicer to her mom.
Oh Craig. That poor kid!
Tomorrow looks interesting...who would have ever thought Emma would be so devious?
I know that some people think that he deserves this but I don't think so yes he has been harsh with Luke yes it was not Luke's fault but Noah is not a bad person he is not evil and I hate to read all this BS from the haters (not you of course )
OK i have to admit that I'm not a Reid lover and everything coming from Reid mouth today made me scream aaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh BS what a freaking user sorry he is completely taking advantage of Luke insecurities about Noah and trashing him. I'm cranky this story is killing me i hate this I really do :( the whole luke reid thing make me sick EWWWWWWW Noah's heart will be broken in a million of pieces he still think that Reid and Luke hate each other **sigh** [/rant] Oh and loved Lucinda today she was fierce as always :D I don't care for Gabriel I think this story is stupid and pointless when you know the show is ending anyway. Even if I don't always agree with you girl I enjoys your recaps thank you so much ♥
I don't think I would use the word "deserve" for Noah. I don't think that Luke and Reid are going to try to punish him (at least, I hope they're not!) if/when they start their relationship. Admittedly, I would like to see Noah hurting over Luke a little bit more, because I feel that it would help him get some perspective on his relationship with Luke (and how good it was). But yes, I agree with you...there's been a lot of Noah hating going around, and while I'm fine with other people doing that (everyone's entitled to their own opinion, and I can't stop it anyway), I still love Noah as a character and will not ever bash him. No one will be able to change my mind about him. I loved him from the start and will continue to do so, no matter how the show ends up
( ... )
Just wanted to say thanks again for posting your recaps. You provide an honest portrayal of what happened on the show with equal opportunities for all storylines. I don't get the sense that you prefer one thing over another and your "tangents" (which I love, BTW) make me wonder too.
The same thought occurred to me about when exactly TPTB started planning this storyline. I had a lightbulb moment today when I realized that I have played right into their hands, probably just like a lot of other people. I think the writers deliberately made Noah appear (somewhat) distant and cold so that when Reid came along people would want Luke to be interested in him, to find someone who would value him. As many have said, there is the "new" Noah and the "old" Noah and I can't figure out exactly when that change occurred, but that might explain the divide. One group can still remember and believe in "old" Noah, while others are remembering what "new" Noah has done.
Oh, thank you so much! I'm so glad you feel that way about my recaps. I do try to keep them balanced most of the time (though my squeeing sometimes overrules everything :-P). Glad my tangents are bearable, too, 'cause I know I go off the deep end sometimes
( ... )
How come Noah didn't ask why Luke answered Reid's cell phone?
We almost had a kiss twice. TPTB are really trying to kill us, aren't they? Okay, so now Noah wants support after pushing Luke away? I loved the scene and all its hurt/comfortness, but it just seemed like Noah's done a 180 turn really quickly.
I guess Noah just figured they were together still? *shrugs* I liked how Luke kinda babbled nervously on the phone with him, and they had the whole "It's Reid now?" thing. :-P The plot is starting to thicken!
I think I can understand Noah wanting Luke to be with him. It doesn't make it any easier for those of us who are upset with how Noah's been treating Luke lately, but to be honest...if I were having surgery and had nobody else, I'd probably do the same damn thing. Surgery scares the crap out of me, so I don't blame Noah at all. I actually kinda liked that they are not together right now but are still supporting one another. And Noah acknowledged the fact that he's been hurting Luke, which made me happy.
Oh, and I TOTALLY agree with Van...the show should definitely end with Nancy running amuck through Old Town killing everyone off! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA fantastic!
Comments 26
Will watch the whole show later tonight. :)
Reply
I think with me, this whole thing concerning Noah and his behavior is extremely personal. I've been through what Luke went through with Noah, so Noah's behavior tends to bother me more than it probably should. Also, I'm a self-proclaimed Luke-girl, so my heart always goes with him first.
This is not to say that I don't love Noah. I've just been struggling with him these last few months because of how he's been pushing Luke away and not even realizing how painful that's been for Luke. I personally don't feel like Reid trashed Noah, especially since he was very calm when talking about him, but I can definitely understand how it could be offensive. I mean, Luke was upset by it, too! So it's totally legit that you would get upset with Reid going on and on about Noah. *hugs*
~G
Reply
I actually like the Reid character...I just don't like him as a romantic interest for Luke *shrug*. He "trashed" Luke to Noah too, so fair play and all. I can see where Luke would gravitate to the interest being shown to him, and I think I can understand Reid's attraction to Luke too. Though, I actually get what Noah was doing in pushing Luke away, at first he was angry and then he was trying to protect himself - and that I totally relate too.
I really dig Carly and Parker's relationship and I really like how she doesn't let him get away with anything. She is a good mom. Faith is so head over heels for Parker, it's almost painful. Nu-Faith isn't my favorite though.
I love Lucinda! As usual, Lily didn't listen to her, but I really liked their scenes and I especially liked her telling nu-Faith to be nicer to her mom.
Oh Craig. That poor kid!
Tomorrow looks interesting...who would have ever thought Emma would be so devious?
*hugs*
Reply
Reply
OK i have to admit that I'm not a Reid lover and everything coming from Reid mouth today made me scream aaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh BS what a freaking user sorry he is completely taking advantage of Luke insecurities about Noah and trashing him.
I'm cranky this story is killing me i hate this I really do :(
the whole luke reid thing make me sick EWWWWWWW
Noah's heart will be broken in a million of pieces he still think that Reid and Luke hate each other **sigh**
[/rant]
Oh and loved Lucinda today she was fierce as always :D
I don't care for Gabriel I think this story is stupid and pointless when you know the show is ending anyway.
Even if I don't always agree with you girl I enjoys your recaps thank you so much ♥
Reply
Reply
Reply
Today's episode really bowled me over. I wasn't expecting all that, but man did I enjoy it! Whew! Hot stuff. And good soapy stuff, too. :-D
~G
Reply
The same thought occurred to me about when exactly TPTB started planning this storyline. I had a lightbulb moment today when I realized that I have played right into their hands, probably just like a lot of other people. I think the writers deliberately made Noah appear (somewhat) distant and cold so that when Reid came along people would want Luke to be interested in him, to find someone who would value him. As many have said, there is the "new" Noah and the "old" Noah and I can't figure out exactly when that change occurred, but that might explain the divide. One group can still remember and believe in "old" Noah, while others are remembering what "new" Noah has done.
Reply
Reply
How come Noah didn't ask why Luke answered Reid's cell phone?
We almost had a kiss twice. TPTB are really trying to kill us, aren't they? Okay, so now Noah wants support after pushing Luke away? I loved the scene and all its hurt/comfortness, but it just seemed like Noah's done a 180 turn really quickly.
Live blogging:
http://www.afterelton.com/node/33416
Interview with Van from AfterElton:
http://www.afterelton.com/TV/gayslives/04-27-10
Reply
I guess Noah just figured they were together still? *shrugs* I liked how Luke kinda babbled nervously on the phone with him, and they had the whole "It's Reid now?" thing. :-P The plot is starting to thicken!
I think I can understand Noah wanting Luke to be with him. It doesn't make it any easier for those of us who are upset with how Noah's been treating Luke lately, but to be honest...if I were having surgery and had nobody else, I'd probably do the same damn thing. Surgery scares the crap out of me, so I don't blame Noah at all. I actually kinda liked that they are not together right now but are still supporting one another. And Noah acknowledged the fact that he's been hurting Luke, which made me happy.
Oh, and I TOTALLY agree with Van...the show should definitely end with Nancy running amuck through Old Town killing everyone off! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA fantastic!
~G
Reply
Leave a comment