Re: [Hi Day two!]n_is_forFebruary 28 2006, 20:59:10 UTC
Ah, well, then.
I do not see a pattern among the numbers; is there something you see which I may be missing?
If we look at it as ages, then the 23 means either yourself or Sha-san, depending on whether the numbers refer to current age or age when entering camp. In the case that it means current age, we can discount 23 as a possible wolf, and focus on the other numbers. 1 is impossible, therefore it can also be discounted. That leaves us with 11, 12, 15, and two 19s.
In the event that it means "upon entering camp," the 23 is not yet eliminated, as you are not confirmed, and leaves us with 11, 12, 15, two 19s, and 23.
Re: [Hi Day two!]for_the_hanFebruary 28 2006, 21:20:51 UTC
Right now, it seems like the most logical interpretation of the clue. So far, it's the only one I've come up that's resulted in three unique numbers. The fact that it includes me makes me feel more confident that I had it correct; with the suspicion I gained in the first round, I think it would be an obvious choice to have a clue that included me.
Re: [Hi Day two!]n_is_forFebruary 28 2006, 21:20:33 UTC
In the first set of numbers, I doubt it applies - there should be three answers, not two. In the second, it might be worth considering - if, of course, "ages upon entering camp" isn't the appropriate answer either.
Re: [Hi Day two!]for_the_hanFebruary 28 2006, 21:25:25 UTC
I don't know about the ages. Mustang and Sha Gojyo are excluded; the former because he is older than twenty three, and the latter because he received the clue. Sano is fifteen. I don't know if any of the others are nineteen, but if it's more than one, then either the clue fails, or they refer to current ages. Of course, if it refers to current ages, it would also fail seeing as how Sano mentioned he's had a birthday since his arrival.
Re: [Hi Day two!]n_is_forFebruary 28 2006, 21:32:13 UTC
Hm. A point.
Between Ash and Sano-san, who would you consider more likely to be a wolf, from your observations?
Sano-san has not, I think, done anything especially suspicious - but neither has Ash. Of course, as one is a tactician, and the other is... Ash, this would, I think, be normal for them both if they were wolves.
And based on my observations, if I were to take everything I've heard and seen at face value, we get the following impossible pairs:
- Near/Ying
- Lupin/Ying
- Hakkai/Near
- Hakkai/Roy
- Hakkai/Ying
- Roy/Obi-Wan
And also, at this point, seeing that Il Palazzo was a sheep means that Sha Gojyo is most likely a sheep, as well.
I was going to attempt a list again, but I don't want to do that until the playing field narrows a bit more.
Reply
I do not see a pattern among the numbers; is there something you see which I may be missing?
If we look at it as ages, then the 23 means either yourself or Sha-san, depending on whether the numbers refer to current age or age when entering camp. In the case that it means current age, we can discount 23 as a possible wolf, and focus on the other numbers. 1 is impossible, therefore it can also be discounted. That leaves us with 11, 12, 15, and two 19s.
In the event that it means "upon entering camp," the 23 is not yet eliminated, as you are not confirmed, and leaves us with 11, 12, 15, two 19s, and 23.
Reply
I tried adding the numbers together and ended up with 1, 2, 3, 6, 10, 10, and 5. I've been trying to find sets of three in each of those.
So far, all I can think of is that three of the numbers (6, 10, 10) are not prime.
Reply
Reply
Reply
1, 4, 8.
Ash, me, or Sano.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Between Ash and Sano-san, who would you consider more likely to be a wolf, from your observations?
Sano-san has not, I think, done anything especially suspicious - but neither has Ash. Of course, as one is a tactician, and the other is... Ash, this would, I think, be normal for them both if they were wolves.
Reply
Reply
There are many ways those numbers could be taken, Ying.
Reply
Leave a comment