Silly self-indulgent squee aside

Sep 09, 2012 01:12

I really loved this ep. ( SPOILERS! )

fandom: doctor who, episode commentary

Leave a comment

Comments 10

dickgloucester September 9 2012, 07:26:49 UTC
The more I think about it, the more I am sure that TV series writers will never be as strict about detail and canon as fans ...

I enjoyed the episode, too, and not least because of David Bradley. I think he's all sorts of brilliant.

Reply

firefly124 September 9 2012, 16:22:37 UTC
He really was all sorts of brilliant. Where do I know him from? I've been trying to place him ever since.

You're right. Show writers just don't put anything like that level of thought into canon details, clearly. Book writers either. "I just Obliviated my parents' every memory of me." A few pages later. "Well, I only know the theory ..." *headdesk*

Reply

dickgloucester September 9 2012, 17:03:58 UTC
Where do you know him from? You are kidding, right?

Reply

firefly124 September 9 2012, 17:47:41 UTC
Oh, FFS, he's Arthur Weasley! *headdesk* Can we blame the fact I skipped the last two movies for that miss? *slinks away*

Or possibly I meant an entirely different actor, the one who played Rory's Dad. Didn't recognize Filch at all.

Reply


dreamy_dragon73 September 9 2012, 12:39:46 UTC
I totally loved this one, too. It was fun. Dinosaurs! Competent companions! Rawr!

Reply

firefly124 September 9 2012, 16:22:52 UTC
Rawr!

Reply


drmm September 9 2012, 15:17:00 UTC
It's Doctor Who -- pesky things like laws regarding painkillers and logic are ignored if they don't fit into the story. ;)

I seriously doubt their laws there are much different than here.

Reply

firefly124 September 9 2012, 16:23:36 UTC
Yeah, hand-waviness abounds. I don't know why I let it surprise me.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

firefly124 September 10 2012, 14:58:32 UTC
He did? I missed that. I'll keep my eye out for it when I rewatch.

The scene with him just having tea and a sandwich while looking down at Earth was brilliant.

Yes, it really was. *nods*

Reply


Leave a comment

Up