Comments | ff_party: Voting: Challenge 4

gabranth in ff_party

Voting: Challenge 4

Sep 13, 2008 23:12

Voting: Challenge 4

We have 28 icons to vote from this week. I recognize that this was a very difficult challenge, especially since some of you have never played the games that were assigned to you. The people with FFXIII had it even tougher - there is no story to base their icon off of! But everyone who submitted did a fabulous job. I was ( Read more... )

round 1, challenge 4, voting

Comments 19

dragon_gypsy September 14 2008, 03:35:34 UTC

ohgod these are amusing. Where to begin ( ... )

clutter_monster September 14 2008, 03:59:55 UTC

Let's see...
1. I really like the concept, but the image is a little difficult to make out to me.
7. Really like this one. With the text and the expression it looks like they just witnessed something that will make a lovely piece of gossip.
11. It took me a little while to figure out what was going on here. It's a nice concept, but the blurriness makes it hard to tell what's going on.
20. Nice way to include a scandalous moment and then Yuna's reaction
21. The background is kinda busy, but I really liked this icon

x_maps September 14 2008, 04:40:51 UTC

2 - Very funny and great animation, but I feel like it's a little fast - a slight pause after the text would have helped.
11 - I love the text but the image is a bit dark - it makes it hard to tell what's going on.
15 - I love this icon - the composition and color scheme work well together, as does the text with his shocked expression.
22 - Great cropping & text, and I love the black bit at the bottom, but the text would be more legible if perhaps it were in white or pink or blue and were more towards the bottom.
25 - Absolutely stunning coloring & texture use, but the texture over Ashe's head is slightly distracting. The text might also benefit from being a different color?

crown_celestial September 14 2008, 05:54:27 UTC

I seriously lol'ed at all the FFVII icons.

5 - The coloring is awesome and I love the image used for the icon. It's so appropriate for the theme.
6 - The colors are a bit dull, but the text fits it so well. I love Cloud's and Reno's expressions. XD
11 - The text is funny, but it's hard to see the image itself.
16 - This icon has great composition! The text and images all flow well together.
21 - The bright, vibrant colors work with concept of it Basch being Guitar Hero.
28 - Awesome cropping and such pretty coloring. ♥

swtxlove September 14 2008, 07:12:17 UTC

2 - I totally laughed when I saw your icon! But it goes by a little fast, at least the text part so maybe make it a teeny bit longer.
9 - Great idea using th cactuar & his needles ;) I love the darkness of it all [sneaky feel to it] & it just has a great composition overall.
16 - Loved the composition & how you stuck Tidus & Shuyin together. Is Shuyin is alter ego? :O
22 - I thought the icon went really well with the theme, I mean look at all that skin, lol! The only thing that was the "scandal" text was a bit hard to read so maybe a lighter font color would've worked better.
28 - Gorgeous coloring & composition!