The Way Out- McGonagall, PG

Aug 11, 2005 12:17

Title: The Way Out
Author: Limyaael
Rating: PG.
Warnings: Only language.
Prompt: Quote 36. “All the world’s a cage.” Heanne Philips. (A guiding spirit, perhaps, but not used in the story itself ( Read more... )

character: minerva mcgonagall, femgen 2005, author: limyaael, fandom: harry potter, titles m-z

Leave a comment

Comments 13

minerva_fan August 11 2005, 17:23:15 UTC
I loved it. The last line had me laughing out loud, though. Very nicely written! :)

Reply

Thank you! limyaael August 18 2005, 23:55:06 UTC
I'm glad the last line worked, since I was originally tempted to add more after it, and then decided to leave it just as it is.

Reply


drusillas_rain August 12 2005, 01:01:14 UTC
nicely done :D

Reply

limyaael August 18 2005, 23:55:27 UTC
Thankya!

Reply


mscyanide August 12 2005, 02:02:32 UTC
Oh, very good. Loved the last line.

Reply

limyaael August 18 2005, 23:55:36 UTC
Thank you. :)

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

limyaael August 18 2005, 23:56:38 UTC
Thanks!

Most of the Minerva characterizations I see in fics- even ones where she's a child or it's long after the War- are completely stern, unbending, and right (sometimes to the point of being self-righteous). I thought the woman who told Peeves how to make mischief and so obviously disliked Umbridge deserved more of a mention.

Reply


a_t_rain August 14 2005, 01:49:57 UTC
Oh, this was lovely -- it's nice to see a younger, less secure, Minerva, and there are lots of great little JKR-ish touches, like the name "Protea Smith." And the last line is brilliant :)

Reply

limyaael August 18 2005, 23:57:07 UTC
Thanks!

I'm not that good at JKR-ish names, so I went with something safe. :) And the last line is a favorite of mine, too.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up