Cargo Cult Science

Aug 11, 2008 01:20

This essay is somewhat dated, but still worth reading.

contrary, science

Leave a comment

Comments 5

kayateia August 11 2008, 16:57:57 UTC
It says a lot about the "evolution debate" really -- the scientists are just being honest about the fact that it is a "theory" (i.e. a very strong working hypothesis that shows a lot of consistency when compared to reality) and that they might be wrong, who knows. The public, not having had a proper science education, has no idea what this terminology means and takes this as a sign of weakness of the idea, like some crackbrained guy thought it up in the shower and started preaching it to gullible scientists. There's not much you can do but gnash your teeth in response to the old "but it's just a THEORY!!" since those types often don't want to be educated, either. "And yours is a non-provable, non-falsifiable hypothesis!" (*crickets*)

"You have a basic misunderstanding of science" doesn't seem to go very far with them.

Reply

vaelen August 11 2008, 18:58:53 UTC
haha, so true.

Reply

eris_star August 11 2008, 19:04:10 UTC
You don't hear the creationists carping too often about gravitational theory, and how it's "only a theory", but maybe that's because trying to ignore gravity tends to have immediate, argument-stopping results:

Idiot: Gravity is "only a theory"! Look, I'll prove it by jumping off this cliff.
*splat*

Reply

Just because you brought it up... kenm August 11 2008, 23:28:37 UTC
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/39512

There are similar articles if you look for them

Reply


vaelen August 11 2008, 18:59:35 UTC
I thought this was an excellent article, although I was a little disturbed when I realized it was from 1974. So little has changed...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up