or your monitor wasn't OMGBRIGHT! like this one was out of the box :)
Just caught a student who pasted the image of a LaTeX formula from Wikipedia into a lab report. I'm thinking give him a zero pending revision, or is that too harsh? (The rest of his report sucks)
Uncertain about that one. Formulas... well if its a well known formula its sort of public knowledge... more than a diagram or a paragraph anyways. It is sort of a picture, but its something that anyone can easily reproduce using latex (or mediawiki for that matter) identically and it wouldn't be plagiarism. It would depend upon the context of the formula in the report, but I'd probably let him off with a warning... tell him to cite his sources or something.
On the other hand, if it sucks that bad, maybe its a good excuse to get him to rewrite the report.
Honestly, I'm just amused that he went to the trouble of copying a latex image of a formula of all things out of wikipedia :P. He could have saved a lot of time and aggravation to take the two seconds to write it in himself or if simple enough just type it.
I assume this is Caleb since the IP address traces back to PAS. :)
It is public knowledge, which is why it's not an OMGPLAGIARISM thing. But it's still using someone else's work, even if it's not using their idea.
I'm trying to emphasize to the students: either create it yourself or tell me who did. I think I'm going to use those exact words today in class. And I've had students lifting diagrams from Wikipedia too without attribution; this is the same sort of thing.
Comments 10
WARK WARK TWEETY WARK!
The second one from the bottom is a tad too bright on my end. I lose a little detail in the feathers on the left hand side.
*fluffs feathers to stay warm*
Reply
Grah, why is this complicated? :)
Reply
Reply
That was a bright glary scene in the first place, so...
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Just caught a student who pasted the image of a LaTeX formula from Wikipedia into a lab report. I'm thinking give him a zero pending revision, or is that too harsh? (The rest of his report sucks)
Reply
On the other hand, if it sucks that bad, maybe its a good excuse to get him to rewrite the report.
Honestly, I'm just amused that he went to the trouble of copying a latex image of a formula of all things out of wikipedia :P. He could have saved a lot of time and aggravation to take the two seconds to write it in himself or if simple enough just type it.
Reply
It is public knowledge, which is why it's not an OMGPLAGIARISM thing. But it's still using someone else's work, even if it's not using their idea.
I'm trying to emphasize to the students: either create it yourself or tell me who did. I think I'm going to use those exact words today in class. And I've had students lifting diagrams from Wikipedia too without attribution; this is the same sort of thing.
Reply
Leave a comment