Leave a comment

Comments 13

fly_meaway January 16 2012, 12:04:11 UTC
I agree with that first line completely. I still haven't gotten over the episode at all. I never experienced something like this before, I think ( ... )

Reply

elli January 16 2012, 22:39:53 UTC
OMG, I read fanfiction!!! I haven't done that in ages.

And I have one time, but it was ages ago and I was already a fangirl to the extreme that there was little else. All the art I made was for that. I read tons of fanfiction and Sherlock hasn't sparked that yet.

I think that is what he asked of Molly. Maybe John had the drug in him and that is why he didn't really notice it wasn't Sherlock but Moriarty?

And Sherlock faked his death to save him.

And I haven no idea if I could handle it. But my knowledge of the whole story is limited.

Reply


roadrunner1896 January 16 2012, 14:00:34 UTC
But how can you keep people guessing if there is a third series already announced? Besides, Sherlock came back alive in the book, too. So I think it was nice to see him watch John and have all these feelings. :D

Also, it would not have changed how I felt, I think. I was sad because of Martin Freeman's wonderful face, not because I thought that Sherlock actually died and now I can think about Sherlock feeling all guilty for not letting John in on the plan.

I also think that Mycroft was in the know, cause he is not that stupid and that the favour Sherlock asked of Molly had to do with the fake death.

I feel so sorry for John and think he needs all the hugs now.

Also, apple porn!!! :D

Reply

elli January 16 2012, 22:42:29 UTC
Your logic is sound ;)
But then at the time I didn't know that and I haven't read any of the books.

I read a fanfic about Mycroft being in on it: http://starjenni.livejournal.com/22842.html Very very good. And IK agree about Molly. Actually I'm sure that is what Sherlock asked of her. I also thin that somehow John has been drugged and that is why he didn't notice the person who fell wasn't Sherloc but Moriarty.

Apple porn!!

Reply

roadrunner1896 January 16 2012, 22:53:08 UTC
Well, if there hadn't been a third series, not showing him alive would have been a mean, ceause then he would have been dead for everyone who doesn't know the books. So I think it was the right decision to show him either way, cause you can't really keep fandom guessing with this one.

John didn't even get close enough to actually see the face and all, no? Also, I think Molly probably did a good job with the mask or whatever she made there for the body. And I think Sherlock actually jumped. No way they could have faked that with John on the phone and watching. But he landed in the dumpster or whatever that was and the body on the ground was already there before, which is why Sherlock wanted John to keep eye contact so he wouldn't notice someone laying there.

Ah, I don't know. Can't wait for series 3. :D

Reply

elli January 17 2012, 14:23:33 UTC
Yes.. that would have been nerve-wrecking and so so evil. It was the same with Adler for me though. They could not have shown she is alive. I think that would have been more interesting.

Landed in the dumpster? I think from that height the chance you'd hit the dumpster is slim... to survice it even slimmer. I'm not sure, but it seems rather impossible to me ;)

But yeah.. the biker was definately a diversion.

And me either :D

Reply


liz_mo January 16 2012, 16:32:04 UTC
Yup! Thought, too, that the very last scene was not necessary. Would have been WAY Cooler!

Benedict and Martin were both absolutely fantastic. Martin with the therapist and also at the graveyard? Totally broke my heart.

Yup, Molly and like with Irene (though her face was smashed in) or (and this isn't mine but a popular one on the lists) jump into the garbage truck, plus blood slowing drugs plus homeless network (guy on bike) to keep JOhn from checking too closely and then whisking away of sherlock on gurney. Inclusion of Mycroft undecided.

The ONLY THING I am a bit disappointed about is the thing with Moriarty. I felt this was a bit of OOC for me. Also, who will he go up against next Season?
UNLESS Moriarty faked, too... ;-)

Reply

elli January 16 2012, 22:48:42 UTC
Exactly. Even knowing there is a season 3 it would have made it a bit more interesting.

Mine too :D

And I agree. It would be shame of Moriarty was dead, also I do think that he is.

Reply


legoline January 16 2012, 22:17:29 UTC
John got hit by a car abd was obviously dizzy, so I wonder if he mixed up things. They were going on about on the roof how Moriarty and Sherlock were the same, so maybe the body that fell was actually Jim's? Hmmm.

Reply

elli January 16 2012, 22:46:52 UTC
I keep thinking the diversion was on purpose. I also tbhink the body that fell was Jims and that John was somehow drugged to believe that it was Sherlock.

I also think Molly was the one who confirmed by death certifice ;)

Reply


lyxzen January 17 2012, 08:38:18 UTC
So eine unglaublich tolle und emotionale Folge! Die letzten 15 min. hab ich geweint wie ein Baby :/

Reply

elli January 17 2012, 14:20:43 UTC
Ich habs ja mit nem Live-Feed gesehen und OMG das war sau frustrierend. Die letzten 15 Minuten wurde der sound voll Scheiße und es stoppte zwischendurch... und ich hatte den krassesten Kloß im Hals. OMG, das hat mich echt fertig gemacht.

Und dieses systematische zerstören einer Person und keiner glaubt einem, da komme ich nicht so wirklich drauf klar.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up