Comments | disneysecret: SECRETS POST #33.

demeter in disneysecret

SECRETS POST #33.

May 08, 2011 13:27

» SECRETS POST #33.

01.

( Read more... )

♯: i ship _____ x _____, non-disney: the swan princess, non-disney: httyd, film: beauty and the beast, non-disney: kung fu panda, ♯: those aren't disney movies, etc: disney (general), `secrets post, +non-disney (secrets post), non-disney: veggie tales, film: tangled, website: tumblr, film: cinderella, non-disney: anastasia, non-disney: cwacom

Comments 89

Suggestions/questions/concerns thread. demeter May 8 2011, 17:30:11 UTC

Please post your suggestions/questions/concerns about this week's secrets here.

General comments thread. demeter May 8 2011, 17:30:43 UTC

Please post your general comments about this week's secrets here.

Comments for secret #01. demeter May 8 2011, 17:34:06 UTC

http://i52.tinypic.com/hrzia1.png

Re: Comments for secret #01. hivers May 8 2011, 17:56:58 UTC

I agree. Disney is generally my favorite, but I was underwhelmed by Toy Story 3. I liked HTTYD a lot more.

Re: Comments for secret #01. princessatta May 8 2011, 18:24:59 UTC

I personally think TS3 should have gotten best picture and HTTYD best animation. It would have been a win/win. But, of course, TS3 would have probably gotten both even if it did win Best Picture. As for the soundtrack...the Academy should be checked for mental stability. It deserved to win hands down.

Re: Comments for secret #01. rainbowishes May 8 2011, 18:26:15 UTC

WORD.

Thread 9

Comments for secret #02. demeter May 8 2011, 17:34:35 UTC

http://i55.tinypic.com/2430z07.jpg

(The comment has been removed)

Re: Comments for secret #02. demeter May 8 2011, 18:05:32 UTC

Non-Disney secrets are allowed this week.

Re: Comments for secret #02. hivers May 8 2011, 18:28:59 UTC

Does this mean non-Disney secrets are allowed for the next submission too, or was it just for this set of secrets?

Thread 8

Comments for secret #03. demeter May 8 2011, 17:34:59 UTC

http://i55.tinypic.com/351z37k.png

Re: Comments for secret #03. demeter May 8 2011, 18:21:00 UTC

Mixed feelings on this one. I agree that it gets old when people go on and on about the stans. But at the same time, it's been pointed out before, that this seems to be one of the safe havens for the complainers. If they were able to openly complain or at the very least share their criticism of Belle, maybe it wouldn't be so big a deal? IDK. Just trying to look at it from both sides. Personally, I've gotten hate comments on YouTube for making an unbiased, rational critical comment of Belle so that is pretty ridiculous ( ... )

OP demeter May 8 2011, 18:28:43 UTC

I'm not saying Belle should be above criticism, or that her actions shouldn't be analysed. I'm just sick and tired of people going on and on about her fans and demonizing the entire B&B fandom when I've seen far, FAR more complaining about the fans than I've EVER seen complaining from actual stans. And everyone says exactly the same thing over and over.

Re: Comments for secret #03. behindgrey_eyes May 8 2011, 18:32:26 UTC

this seems to be one of the safe havens for the complainers. If they were able to openly complain or at the very least share their criticism of Belle, maybe it wouldn't be so big a deal?

THIS.

Its not so much that I want to complain about Belle or anything. I think she's awesome, but I think people are scared to dare whisper they might not love her as much as the others, never mind come out with that they really don't like her, for fear of of a clusterfuck of shitstorms.

Thread 25