Most Robbie Thompson episodes (all but 2 that I can think of) seem like he's writing out his fantasy and forcing it into Supernatural where it doesn't fit at all. I'm not a fan of his writing style because of that and could nit pick this episode to death for some of the reasons you covered and many more.
After several times intending to visit your recaps of Teh Hottie Show, I finally made it this time. So thank you very much for the link at all_spn, honey.
O dear. Looks like I'm the only one here, who really liked TSNPLH. I read your rant and all the comments above and now I'm starting to think if we all wached the same episode... Or if I did I miss something? *thinky-thinky*
Yeah, despite the fact that I'm not the biggest Robbie Thompson fangirl, I was surprised how much his script worked for me, this time. *nods**nods* - Okeh, I have to admit you and my dear fellow comentors above about the fact that, in fact, there wasn't much to do for our Sammeh [what I don't like as much you, m'dear], but this *coughs* 'phenomenon' started much earlier; don't you think?
And, hit me, but I like Charlie. - And, I liked Becky too, btw. Also, au contraire to Carver's last seasons, this time the comparison(s) between Winchester(s) and guest star(s) worked for me.
Because Robbie T. wrote said comparison(s) with mucho more sure instinct than we had to
( ... )
Thanks for your comments, and I'm glad you explained how you felt. There is a comment farther up that simply says the commenter disagreed with everything but didn't say why. I'd rather have a comment like yours any day.
Comments 41
and I rarely read reviews now, I remember back on season 4 and 5 I read reviews from 4 people
but hey next episode we have Sam and looks like he actually has things to do :D
this: "Don't worry, Jensen, we've got a convention in San Pedro this weekend." HAHAHAhahaha
Reply
Reply
Reply
O dear. Looks like I'm the only one here, who really liked TSNPLH. I read your rant and all the comments above and now I'm starting to think if we all wached the same episode... Or if I did I miss something?
*thinky-thinky*
Yeah, despite the fact that I'm not the biggest Robbie Thompson fangirl, I was surprised how much his script worked for me, this time.
*nods**nods*
- Okeh, I have to admit you and my dear fellow comentors above about the fact that, in fact, there wasn't much to do for our Sammeh [what I don't like as much you, m'dear], but this *coughs* 'phenomenon' started much earlier; don't you think?
And, hit me, but I like Charlie. - And, I liked Becky too, btw.
Also, au contraire to Carver's last seasons, this time the comparison(s) between Winchester(s) and guest star(s) worked for me.
Because Robbie T. wrote said comparison(s) with mucho more sure instinct than we had to ( ... )
Reply
And for you, my icon is double-suit hotties. ;)
Reply
*melts into a big puddle of Helio goo*
( ... )
Reply
Leave a comment