Leave a comment

Comments 198

missyjack January 26 2011, 22:56:00 UTC
Wow - absolutely brilliant! Just loved the segue between show and fandom. There's just so much here I'll be watching again and again. A real triumph m'dear!

Reply

counteragent January 26 2011, 22:57:32 UTC
THANK YOU SO MUCH. I was like "is anyone out there? OH GOD NO ONE IS."

I'm super super pleased you (in particular) liked it.

Reply

missyjack January 27 2011, 01:56:53 UTC
I've loved the soulless Sam storyline, and i think it's worked precisely because its elicited such a strong reaction.

Of course your vid highlights exactly what fandom is for - fans fulfilling their fantasies about the characters, and writing our own version of the story.

Reply

counteragent January 27 2011, 02:17:02 UTC
I have enjoyed the Soulless Sam storyline intellectually, even while it's gutted me emotionally. Which is not something I expected to feel after five seasons of manpain!

And yes, that is what fandom is for! Thank god.

Reply


deirdre_c January 26 2011, 23:03:01 UTC
I LOVE IT SO MUCH, WORDS CANNOT EXPRESS! MY LOVE CANNOT BE TEXTUALLY RENDERED. Dean & fandom's mutual FREAK OUT over Sam's missing soul. WE WILL COLLECTIVELY PUNCH DOPPLESAMMER IN THE FACE.

Brilliantly done. The original footage was incredible. Bravissimo!

Reply

counteragent January 27 2011, 02:18:06 UTC
OH THANK GOD YOU GOT IT.

I was TERRIFIED you'd hate it or be like "that's nice" *head pat of confusion*. Terrified.

Reply

deirdre_c January 27 2011, 14:49:36 UTC
It's interesting watching the vid again and then also reading through other viewers' comments and feeling this great outpouring of kinship with you and your expression of what has happened to certain fans in S6. Because I personally keenly feel so unhappy, dismayed, even betrayed by the loss of true!Sam the first half of this season and at the same time roll my eyes and kick myself for allowing this silly show and this one fictional character to affect me so very deeply and yet-- still, at the same time-- this self-awareness of the triviality of how the show handles Sam's fate in the grand scheme of my life has not helped me GET OVER my visceral anger and despondency with it, even as intellectually I can admire the plot arc and what the writers have done.

And it is clear to me from the other comments you've received that this is only one particular experience among all the interpretations/relationships people have with SPN. But it is mine, and I thank you for articulating it with such complexity and humor and artistry.

Reply

counteragent January 27 2011, 15:06:25 UTC
*bursts directly into grateful, shaming tears. No, really*

That is EXACTLY what I was trying to say. EXACTLY.

Reply


neros_violin January 26 2011, 23:12:02 UTC
This is BRILLIANT, zomg. I have watched it four times already, and I pick up something new with each viewing - seriously, seriously clever and visually awesome and the song is perfect. I am AWE of your skills!

Reply

counteragent January 27 2011, 02:19:07 UTC
Thank you so much! You've made me very happy, as "multiple viewings" is what ever vidder craves to hear.

Reply


amnisias January 26 2011, 23:12:16 UTC
Holy brotherhood, I am totally flailing here. You are a real genius, honestly. I just love how you used the different parts of the song, and the mix of original source, web content and counteragentcontent. There are even red shoes in there!!!

Reply

counteragent January 27 2011, 02:19:38 UTC
Thank you so much!

Oh, yes. There are red shoes. In the queue of crazy, I'm first in line.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

counteragent January 27 2011, 02:22:36 UTC
Thanks again so much for your help!

ILU!!!! And Sam.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up