Comments | cot_tossed: The Tenth Doctor category

cot_tossed

The Tenth Doctor category

Feb 14, 2009 17:53

This is the first time I've actually posted here from the web. Why is Ikea advertising on my journal? (I mean, I knew when I chose a plus account that there'd be ads. But Ikea? Do they know of my love for their $2 breakfasts?)

1. Feeling By Proxy by Fid_gin and Unfolded73 ( Read more... )

Comments 12

fourzoas February 14 2009, 16:25:59 UTC

I admit that I fully expected the thump for the way I dealt with Tom in that story. I've moved on from that particular impulse, and from time to time I wonder how I would rewrite it were I to revisit it. I'm glad, however, that you seem to have found something in the story that was enjoyable.

fid_gin February 14 2009, 22:05:35 UTC

But then there's a reference to “the chocolatey back of [the Doctor's] suit jacket”, and ... no. Just no. The Doctor is not an Easter egg, not even when he's wearing brown.

Yeah, well, that's just like, your opinion, man. ;)

ladys_paladin February 25 2009, 07:40:50 UTC

First the fic is entirely from Alt!ten’s point of view there are chapters where Rose is barely mentioned. Yet for you it’s all about Rose and Rose bashing. It is in fact about Alt!ten facing his own mortality and trying desperately to make things as right as he can before he dies having made so many mistakes in the beginning ( ... )

cot_tossed February 27 2009, 01:45:54 UTC

It's obvious that you had a lot of sophisticated and interesting ideas behind this fic. Unfortunately, the quality of the writing was too poor to adequately convey them. I shall stand behind my review.

ladys_paladin February 27 2009, 04:51:50 UTC

My response is here http://cot-tossed.livejournal.com/10586.html?thread=60506#t60506