Asking again...

Jun 21, 2010 14:00

If it was proven to you, beyond the shadow of a doubt, that Jesus is in fact God, would you worship Him?

Leave a comment

Comments 89

bokuniwa June 21 2010, 21:14:49 UTC
1) My first hesitation is by your use of the word "prove". The statement "Jesus is God" is not something that can be proven in the strict sense of the word. However, I'll assume the broader meaning of "shown to be highly probable."

2) My willingness to worship an entity would be contingent on two things:
A) the consequence for lack of worship
B) the nature of God

The nature of God, were He to exist, as evidenced by the Bible and what we can observe, is at worst a malevolent and at best indifferent being. This is not a being worthy of my worship. Sufficient threat of punishment might persuade me to half-heartedly worship God/Jesus, but presumably God/Jesus would see through it anyway. Naturally, the consequence of non-worship and nature of God would have to be "proven"/shown to be highly probable.

Reply

ex_restless June 21 2010, 21:20:20 UTC
Why would 2A matter? If a being exists whose very nature is such that the only reasonable response is worship, why would you consider the consequences of not worshiping? Why would consequences play into the equation at all?

Reply

bokuniwa June 21 2010, 21:22:51 UTC
What I meant was that if 2B was not sufficient, 2A may come into play. Sorry for the confusion.

Reply

ex_restless June 21 2010, 21:24:28 UTC
Oh ok, sorry. It was actually more clear on my second reading. So when you read the Gospel and the manner in which Jesus presents God and interprets the OT, if you were convinced of Jesus' divinity and thus that it is He who best interprets Jewish and Christian Scripture, what about God as revealed by Jesus Christ seems monstrous to you?

Reply


ex_restless June 21 2010, 21:18:58 UTC
It's a difficult premise with which to work, since in this life almost nothing is proven without a shadow of a doubt. Certainly many things are proven beyond a reasonable doubt, but that is a different standard altogether. And I know you're asking a hypothetical, but I think it's perhaps better phrased in a way that is realistic in this lifetime: If you became firmly convinced that Jesus is God, would you worship Him ( ... )

Reply

advoir June 21 2010, 21:35:51 UTC
:)

Reply


redstar826 June 21 2010, 22:07:32 UTC
Quite possibly, but I don't actually expect that to happen.

Reply


ashrayne June 22 2010, 00:52:40 UTC
Why does Jesus being proven to be God need to effect worship?

Reply

ex_restless June 22 2010, 01:04:42 UTC
It doesn't seem that the OP said that it does. He asked if it would.

Reply

ashrayne June 22 2010, 01:08:23 UTC
Forgive me; I should have clarified. I did not mean to imply that the OP said it would.

I'm merely asking why such a revelation would effect worship in the first place.

Reply

ex_restless June 22 2010, 01:10:03 UTC
Well, what do you think. Would the understanding of Jesus as God be cause to worship Him? How would such an understanding of Jesus' divinity affect your relationship to God, whether spiritual, intellectual, or otherwise?

Reply


raven_moon June 22 2010, 03:36:48 UTC
No. He's a ponce, and his dad's a right git. Noting worth worshipping there.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up