Comments | caladria: Miller's Crossing

caladria

Miller's Crossing

Dec 02, 2007 12:00

I seem to be the only person (judging from a quick flick round) but I don't really have a problem with Sam not being there. She's The Man. The Men don't get to do fun stuff. She was the one sat at home arguing with Landry and Jack and the IOA til they got Steve through the Gate to Earth (plus Milky Way coding and Pegasus coding I would assume ( Read more... )

sga, episode review

Comments 7

pengyn December 2 2007, 13:57:07 UTC

There is always going to be that mad contingent in fandom that completely "forgets" the fact that we've been told Sam will only be in 14 episodes this season.

So when they complain that they didn't see her in an episode, I'm like "grow up already". It was clearly a McKay (squared) episode and there was nothing in the storyline that could have utilised Sam to maximum effect.

To be honest I felt a bit "meh" about the first half of the episode.. but midway it picked up. I loved the Rodney/Jeannie banter. Kept thinking this is a window into the sibling arguements that must have gone on between David and Kate.

And Ronon... hawt!

caladria December 2 2007, 20:09:46 UTC

I'm like "grow up already".

Let's be fair, you're like that an awful lot anyway *g*

I just love the teaser for Zelenka, who is pocket sized and bops people over the head with a metal pole, and the snarky blonde scientist..

Respectfully disagree majorsamfan December 3 2007, 21:53:43 UTC

The same could be said for those who missed Jack in S8-S10 or those who fought to bring Daniel back or those who lobbied about Janet or Carson or Torri... (I'm assuming you told them to "grow up", too, from Caladria's reply to your comment?:D ( ... )

Re: Respectfully disagree pengyn December 3 2007, 22:40:36 UTC

On the contrary actually. I would never begrudge anyone for their feelings regarding the loss of a favourite character. Jack is one of mine, and I do know there was much anger after his departure. Whereas my feelings about him leaving have settled, I understand that that is not so for everyone ( ... )

Thread 5

6beforelunch December 2 2007, 17:40:20 UTC

I seem to be the only person (judging from a quick flick round) but I don't really have a problem with Sam not being there.

I didn't mind it either. She can't take the time from running Atlantis to deal with working on the nanites. That makes sense to me. I do wish we'd gotten a mention, but I can deal with it either way.

caladria December 2 2007, 20:17:00 UTC

A mention would have been nice (actually, I'd prefer to know why Teyla wasn't there if Ronan was because that doesn't really make sense)