Dearest Stephanie Meyer:

[lovely_fugitive]

"Twilight" is the most inane, average book I have read in the past year and I can say that without hesitation. I'm pretty prolific when it comes to books- I will read almost anything if it seems interesting to me. Well, you must have a great marketing team, so I guess that's why it looked so alluring in the first place

Comments

[mrs_robotnik]

[mrs_robotnik]

:)

[darelose]

AMEN. And don’t even get me started from the feminist angle of this. I not a huge fan of feminism (this is as a female myself) or discuss it ever in any form and even I will tell people how bad of an example this book is setting for young girls and girls of all ages really. Maybe I wouldn’t hate it so much if it was well written, but, like you said, it is cliched and lacks character depth in a big way. It, again, like you said, honestly does read like a bad fan fiction. Oh, and Stephanie Meyer, it’s not “breaking the rules” or edgy or whatever you think it is to completely disregard vampire canon because you are too lazy to write it. VAMPIRES CAN'T GO OUT IN THE SUN AND THEY SUCK THE BLOOD OF HUMANS! I’m embarrassed for how many girls my age and older are apparently captivated by this terrible, terrible phenomenon. I could go on all day about this (and have), but I won’t take up any more space or time. In conclusion, I very much enjoyed your letter. It was well thought out and well said.

[thereallola]

All I could say the whole time Edward was being all "protective" of her and trying to tell her she couldn't see Jacob, was, "If Michael EVER tried to tell me I couldn't do something..."
Talk about controlling...
The only thing Meyer breaks the rules about is vampire mythology. They don't wither away in the sunlight, they SPARKLE. *rolls eyes*
:P

[lovely_fugitive]

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it.

So... I understand that most people on this community complain about Meyer and that, apparently, I am not creative enough with my hatred. But that's okay!

[gaspardgroupie]

'I not a huge fan of feminism (this is as a female myself)'

This confuses me.

[cesaretech]

She centered her idea around Romeo and Juliet and Wuthering Heights, and did not have the reading comprehension to understand the message behind those stories. Many of her readers are in the same league.

[aceofhadeon]

She centered her idea around Romeo and Juliet

A shame it didn't end like that work.

[scribblyness_x]

A+++

[_jeuxjaloux]

i'd rather a jacob come take me away ;)

[cpufaye]

Just can't agree more. This book is sooooo Mary sue!