Comments | bigmamag: Star Trek slash analysis thing I'm too lazy to title

bigmamag

Star Trek slash analysis thing I'm too lazy to title

May 23, 2009 06:51

So I started this thing as a normal LJ post about a het pairing in Star Trek and my thoughts on it. It grew, and grew, and became this fancy and pseudo-coherent analysis of Kirk/Spock and how their relationship grows and is the main point of the entire movie. And you know, it was actually hella fun to write because I think that in this fandom, ( Read more... )

slash, thinky thoughts, meta, writing, their love is oh so canon, boldly slashing where i've never slashed, space husbands

Comments 125

jenlynn820 May 23 2009, 13:33:21 UTC

Now watch me KOCK it all up. :D

You win for that line alone :P

I couldn't agree more with your analysis and enjoyed reading this :)

bigmamag May 23 2009, 15:07:00 UTC

I have a strange affinity for that line as well. :P Thank you for reading it right back! It's good to know I'm not nuts.

lemon_drop151 May 23 2009, 13:40:49 UTC

Freaking awesome essay. I concur completely.

Cheers!

bigmamag May 23 2009, 15:07:20 UTC

Thanks for partaking!

ravendoe May 23 2009, 13:59:10 UTC

OMG I love you <3
Thanks :)

bigmamag May 23 2009, 15:08:54 UTC

You only declared that in the heat of the moment. :P Seriously, thanks for reading.

okmewriting May 23 2009, 14:09:17 UTC

Love your analysis. Think I need to watch the film yet again.

bigmamag May 23 2009, 15:10:00 UTC

I think I've seen it so much by now that I could probably quote most of it. Shameful, really.

emocezi May 23 2009, 14:30:09 UTC

Since Spock Prime is 155 years old, it's safe to say that he could flawlessly do a mind meld that only gave Jim what he wanted to give him. Make of that what you will.

This is very true, but what you seem to have forgotten is that As a 155 year old Vulcan, everyone one of the origional crew members is now dead and gone.

What would you do if after, I'm gonna go with 75 years, of not seeing your very best friend in the entire universe/possible lover of many years, in a cave. Spock Prime, after a lifetime of dealing with Kirk has....mostly embraced quite a few emotions.

I don't condone the fiction written about Kirk and Spock suddenly being bonded through the mind meld, but Spock Prime would have been feeling A HELL OF A LOT OF EMOTION at this time.

With Jim telling him that he and the Spock of this time aren't friends, he would have wanted to let Kirk know that the two of them were indeed old friendsOkay, so now that I'm done ranting on the subject of mind melding and whatnot.....HOLY HELL GIRL!!! You're a Trek Newbie????? I ( ... )

bigmamag May 23 2009, 15:19:42 UTC

And you make a great point. Put into perspective like that, I can understand why Spock Prime would unload all that. I guess my biggest gripe are the fics where they can hear each other's thoughts or Kirk retained memories of the original time line versions doing it. No matter how much Spock Prime missed him, I doubt he'd download porn into Jim's head. :P A romantic feeling or two, maybe.

Ahaha yes, it has been less than two weeks since I've seen anything with Star Trek. I vaguely remember Picard but I never watched it. I'm an English major and English teacher, so that's probably why it seems like I know so much because this is just literary analysis but infinitely more fun and loltastic. Plus I'm a dirty cheat and lean heavily on Memory Alpha, like with Spock Prime's age (I am SHIT with math, I had to use a calculator.)

I mean, I guess it's a not-so-bad thing because they didn't make it into a bigger deal, if that makes sense. I mean, they could have started their relationship at the beginning and we could have had the ( ... )

emocezi May 23 2009, 23:56:46 UTC

No matter how much Spock Prime missed him, I doubt he'd download porn into Jim's head. :P A romantic feeling or two, maybe.

I do agree with this statement...HOWEVER, the downloaded porn makes fanfiction that much more interesting. :p Providing it's well written of course.

And I would have liked at least a warning shot across the bow before they just LAUNCH the Hetero!canon into the Spock.Uhura.

And Kirk and Spock fighting over a girl was an actual episode in TOS. It's titled Amok Time and deals with Spock under going Pon Farr. I could certainly go into more detail, but I think I'll just let you wander into that little jewel of wonder by yourself. :D

bigmamag May 24 2009, 01:13:34 UTC

Yeah I have to admit, I did save a fanfic with actual mind reading, but it was too hot to stand and it had Pon Farr.

Oh I saw Amok Time, it was my first episode. I heard about that shit and *zip* I went and watched it on youtube. But see, I don't care about T'Pring because he didn't really know her and she chose Kirk as her champion, and they didn't fight because they both wanted her. OMG, I could count the ways I love that episode forever.

"He does not burn as I do."

"My heart is flame."

"Captain...JIM!"

♥♥♥

Thread 6