Thank you for actually writing what about half of us believe to be true about Snape killing Dumbledore - as the icon says, "I trust Snape, because if Dumbledore was that dumb we've jumped the shark."
I'm not so sure about Harry being a Horcrux, because in order for that to be the case, Voldemort would have had to 1) be trying NOT to kill him all the time it seemed like one of his main goals (like book four in the graveyard); 2) intended that when he aimed the killing curse at Harry after killing both his parents, and essentially defeated himself to begin with. Unless he somehow turned him into a Horcrux later...
Anyway, it's obviously a matter of personal preference guiding our opinions in the first place, since I really don't think we've got enough information to reason logically from the books. Nice work! I like the beginning; waiting eagerly for more.
Comments 2
I'm not so sure about Harry being a Horcrux, because in order for that to be the case, Voldemort would have had to 1) be trying NOT to kill him all the time it seemed like one of his main goals (like book four in the graveyard); 2) intended that when he aimed the killing curse at Harry after killing both his parents, and essentially defeated himself to begin with. Unless he somehow turned him into a Horcrux later...
Anyway, it's obviously a matter of personal preference guiding our opinions in the first place, since I really don't think we've got enough information to reason logically from the books.
Nice work! I like the beginning; waiting eagerly for more.
Reply
*hugs*
It's excellent
Reply
Leave a comment