Comments | badfic_quotes: If An OOC Mars Writes An OOC Letter, And There's No Venus To Read It...

ran_mouri82 in badfic_quotes

If An OOC Mars Writes An OOC Letter, And There's No Venus To Read It...

Jan 06, 2010 22:56

To my dismay, the tiny Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon section of the Pit is dominated by blubbery, Rei/Minako (Mars/Venus) fic. In PGSM, the live action Sailor Moon series, Minako's story is tragic, but this fic is downright weepy:

Letter

( Is It Really Badfic? YES. )

sailor moon

Comments 15

chickenperson52 January 7 2010, 04:11:34 UTC

...sigh. PGSM fandom, why?

iceshade January 7 2010, 05:55:13 UTC

Act Pi, but don't tell Usagi, or she'll want to eat it
I think I love you (TAS y/y?)

mochi_hime January 7 2010, 13:28:39 UTC

There should be an Abridged series! But the Sailor Moon Hell subtitle parodies on YouTube rock my world, especially A Sailor Moon Hell Christmas. DEATH DANCE PARTY! XD

iceshade January 7 2010, 18:53:56 UTC

no, but there is! and they constantly make jokes like that! here's a link to ep. 1

iceshade January 7 2010, 18:54:52 UTC

oh wait, that's notPGSM, it's just regular sailor moon

Thread 5

anonymous January 7 2010, 22:37:09 UTC

I have read all of two good PGSM fics. Srsly, it's like anime Sailor Moon-level wangst pervades everything linked to it.

ran_mouri82 January 8 2010, 00:33:21 UTC

Even the anime isn't as angst-ridden as this. >.< The lovelorn letter format didn't help at all.

catchingspirit January 8 2010, 22:54:33 UTC

What makes me sad is I can bet there were bunches of comments saying how wonderful and touching it was.

It touched me in bad places. D:

ran_mouri82 January 8 2010, 23:27:58 UTC

There were only three reviews, but sadly, yes. One even said the fic made them cry.

catchingspirit January 8 2010, 23:29:25 UTC

I cling to you for hope. We have different interps of things sometimes, but yours always make sense and it's fun to just discuss them. I don't have to beat myself to death by headdesking like I do with some of this stuff. XD

mochi_hime January 8 2010, 23:41:36 UTC

Well, things should be open in fic and RP; that's what makes them fun! But some things are obviously OOC, and when we love the characters involved, it's downright painful.

Thread 5

imapandabear January 15 2010, 22:53:41 UTC

I really like the PGSM!Rei/Minako pairing, but this... This just doesn't make sense. D: I'm all for yuri, but please stick to the canon! Make it realistic! Damn.

ran_mouri82 January 16 2010, 02:26:55 UTC

Right, make it realistic! It's like having Rei of all people go on about frolicking in a dewy meadow. Just no. >.< Really.