Indian Athlete Fails Gender Test

Dec 18, 2006 20:01

Thought this was an interesting article, especially regarding our recent discussion about such designations ( Read more... )

femininity, india, masculinity, gender, athletes

Leave a comment

Comments 11

caatinga December 18 2006, 20:08:49 UTC
Incidentally, here's a shot of Seema Antil, mentioned at the end of the article as an athlete charged with "doping" (not sure exactly what substance that entails).


... )

Reply


oldtactics December 18 2006, 20:25:16 UTC
This is pretty much the most useless piece of journalism I've ever read.

Reply

forsberg21 December 19 2006, 00:03:41 UTC
I wouldn't call it the most useless piece of journalism.. I mean, hello? Britney Spears?.. but don't you think it reveals how some of these procedures expose a populace rather ignorant of gender designations?

Reply

oldtactics December 19 2006, 00:05:36 UTC
Yes, I agree, definitely. I just found it a bit pointless - no explanation of what this gender testing entails, no explanation of what exactly they're 'implying' with the findings. Regardless, certainly something that I'm glad is being brought up :)

Reply

forsberg21 December 19 2006, 17:43:46 UTC
Good point! I guess they leave that open-ended, I suppose, to be politically correct.

Reply


ladyofannwn December 18 2006, 22:53:59 UTC
a gender test? i'm a little confused.

Reply


dani_moonstar December 19 2006, 03:31:57 UTC
i agree with the people that commented above. it is a bad piece.

that being said, i think i know where the problem might be...

i know a girl who does wight lifting. she is very androgynous and very strong, you could almost say "abnormally" strong for a girl. so she can't be in a competition with girls, but she can't be in a competition with boys.
so, her problem is that she can train, but....she can't be in a competition. it's a big deal for her because she is pretty good at it.

Reply

gaelfarce December 19 2006, 04:04:04 UTC
There was an article about a Canadian MtF who is a mountain biker and there was some controversy about a woman who placed second to her. This woman wore a shirt on the podium with "100% Pure Woman" on it.

Reply

caatinga December 19 2006, 04:49:26 UTC
Yep, Michelle Dumaresque.


... )

Reply

caatinga December 19 2006, 04:50:49 UTC
whoopt, *Dumaresq

Reply


Leave a comment

Up