Leave a comment

Comments 46

India, Indonesia to Get $25 Firefox Smartphones apostle_of_eris June 12 2014, 18:00:33 UTC
Remember “the digital divide”?
AHH-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-ha

Reply

Re: India, Indonesia to Get $25 Firefox Smartphones andrewducker June 12 2014, 20:10:10 UTC
Getting smaller every day!

But even having "dumb" mobile phones was really useful to people in poorer countries. Tracking weather, or which markets had the highest prices has been a boon.

Reply


steer June 12 2014, 20:28:08 UTC
Going to put this here before I forget: Election in ExampleVille D'Hondt method with no modifications, 10 regions, 4 parties (ABCD), 4 seats a region 600 voters a region -- numbers chosen to make the example simple but doesn't depend on numbers, You can construct a similar result with 10 seats a region and 100,000 voters -- differences in voting will be less startling ( ... )

Reply

danieldwilliam June 13 2014, 09:15:15 UTC
Are you sure about d'Hondt not favouring large (in the electoral region) parties. If I put exactly the same votes into a Sainte-Lange it comes out with 10 seats each. My observation of comparing D'hondt and S-L is that S-L tends to see smaller parties just winning one extra seat and larger parties just losing that final seat.

Reply

danieldwilliam June 13 2014, 09:41:26 UTC
I think any non-preferential system with regional constitutencies is going to be prone to this sort of effect. You get proportionality within the region, not necessarily across the whole chamber ( ... )

Reply

steer June 13 2014, 10:20:00 UTC
Yes, it is an arbitrary example finely balanced to show De Hondt favouring small parties. I think dh minimises the mean error between proportion of seats and proportion of votes. Got a long plane trip so might try to prove it. Can't remember the circumstances under which that is true, I think it is more obvious in Jefferson's formulation. Dh is pretty much what I would come up with I think. All systems have their flaws and any regional system you could come up with similar crazy.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up