as for creativedv8tion's vote...yamara34June 28 2009, 15:40:24 UTC
Hey come on kids, I can understand why one could prefer Tin Man over the original
It was made as a steampunk retelling of the story (and a sort of sequel? That bit was a little unclear)
The original is a classic 1930s musical which is a totally different genre
Partly why I love the original so much is because it was one of the first movies I ever saw and I know all the songs
Partly why I rated Tin Man 7 and could see someone liking it better is because either they didn't see Wizard of Oz first, or they saw it and it didn't appeal to them in the same way. It's more of a kid's movie while Tin Man is for a bit older crowd
Comments 3
It was made as a steampunk retelling of the story (and a sort of sequel? That bit was a little unclear)
The original is a classic 1930s musical which is a totally different genre
Partly why I love the original so much is because it was one of the first movies I ever saw and I know all the songs
Partly why I rated Tin Man 7 and could see someone liking it better is because either they didn't see Wizard of Oz first, or they saw it and it didn't appeal to them in the same way. It's more of a kid's movie while Tin Man is for a bit older crowd
Reply
Accidentally rated Tin man a '6', having not seen it.
I loathe people who do that with intentionally.
If you play again include 1985's Return to Oz I remember it being 'bad', but that's about all.
Reply
Very strange, scary film for a young girl, though (which I was when I first saw it)
Reply
Leave a comment