I found myself idly wondering if I'd ever stayed at the same hotel in Las Vegas twice, and it took me a minute. I've stayed at the Plaza twice.
Aug 2001, bachelor party, Luxor
Apr 2003, Grand Canyon trip with Jenn, Key Largo (gone)
Aug 2004,
BARGE, Rio
Nov 2004, pinball fun nite/hey let's go to Vegas, Ryan's timeshare
Aug 2005,
BARGE, Plaza
Aug 2006,
BARGE, Main Street Station
Apr 2007, Jenn's birthday, Plaza*
Aug 2007,
BARGE, Binion's
I can't remember the name of Ryan's timeshare, but it was a nice enough place. No poker room, though.
Apparently I've only stayed on the strip once. I would recommend Main Street and Ryan's timeshare. Binion's was decent. The Plaza scares me a little. Key Largo was especially bad, but it's closed, so I really can't recommend it now.