A Yiddish proverb

Jan 20, 2011 14:33

Does someone know the Yiddish analogue of the Russian proverb "Яблоко от яблони недалеко падает" (literally - "The apple doesn't fall far from the tree", the English "Like father, like son")?
Something about cat's babies inevitably mewing.

Thanks.

Upd. Cross to ru_yiddish .

Leave a comment

Comments 22

pne January 20 2011, 12:53:18 UTC
I can't help you with Yiddish, but in modern German, the proverb is very similar: "Der Apfel fällt nicht weit vom Stamm", the apple doesn't fall far from the (tree) trunk.

Reply

nu57 January 20 2011, 13:31:02 UTC
Thanks, so it's written also here (this site quotes it in many languages, but unfortunately not in Yiddish)

Reply

pne January 20 2011, 14:20:18 UTC
Ah, I should have followed your link. Apologies.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

(The comment has been removed)

hector_von_kyiv January 20 2011, 13:27:36 UTC
A Captain Obvious sort of thing :)

Reply

(The comment has been removed)


marnanel January 20 2011, 14:15:06 UTC
I can't help you with the proverb, but it may help in other ways to know that "Yiddish" starts with a vowel, so it's "a Yiddish proverb", not "an Yiddish proverb".

Reply

pne January 20 2011, 14:21:28 UTC
"Yiddish" starts with a vowel

Should be "...starts with a consonant", of course.

Reply

marnanel January 20 2011, 14:31:12 UTC
Er, yes. Thinko. Thanks for pointing that out.

Reply

nu57 January 20 2011, 14:52:20 UTC
Thank you very much for your wise correction of my stupid misprint.

Reply


muckefuck January 20 2011, 15:20:18 UTC
I don't know your one about cats, but there is a Yiddish version of the Russian/English/German/etc. saying, i.e. "Dos epl falt nit vayt fun boym." There's also an equivalent of "Like father, like son" ("Vi der tate, azoy der zun").

Reply

nu57 January 20 2011, 15:26:35 UTC
Thanks! Here in ru_yiddish they suggested also some other versions, including the one about cats.

Reply

muckefuck January 20 2011, 20:15:08 UTC
I've never seen that one about cats in any Yiddish source. I'd be curious to know where ma_rs learned it.

Reply

nu57 January 20 2011, 20:32:04 UTC
I'll ask her

Reply


Leave a comment

Up