What does this writing critique group do, anyway?

Jul 20, 2010 13:52

I was just corresponding with someone who is reluctant to share their writing with a group. Had some thoughts on this I wanted to share here ( Read more... )

critique, writer's group

Leave a comment

Comments 5

vikingtim July 21 2010, 19:16:27 UTC
ok, good news bad news time. the job situation got fixed, which is good, bad that it is a second shift one though, so I am going to have to bow out of the group. wanted to be a part of it.

Reply

wylde_writer July 22 2010, 03:36:53 UTC
I'm sorry to hear that. hopefully you can at least join us some time for the social get-togethers. If your schedule changes in the future and you're able to do the workgroup, let me know.

Reply

wylde_writer July 22 2010, 03:40:49 UTC
ps - your icon cracks me up. :)

Reply


raging_gargoyle July 21 2010, 20:17:58 UTC
Actually the writing groups I have been a part of have had the opposite problem. Everyone was all praise and amazement at anything anyone wrote, without any real critique at all. I think the most verbose critique I heard as part of the latest one was "That isn't really my genre, so I don't know what to think about. But it sounded nice!"

Reply

wylde_writer July 22 2010, 03:39:17 UTC
I think there are many groups that come together more because everyone wants social support for the process of writing, and less because they are seriously working on craft issues.

I think we can achieve both, if there is some basic structure to follow.

I'm a little behind getting those guidelines together; some stuff in RL has been intruding. They'll be out soon though, and I invite your input on them as well. I want this to be a process that meets many if not all of everyone's writerly needs.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up