"Although we have not seen the material that Berger et al base their results on..."
So I guess we'll see. Their paper would have been peer reviewed, but if their concerns and objections are addressed well by Berger, then the ball's still very much in play.
"Our evidence ... Berger / failed to review existing documentation, much of it published by Nelson or Fitzpatrick ... remains unearthed by Fitzpatrick and Nelson / only miles from Berger's two sites. ... stepping outside his own area of expertise ... "You just can't walk in and cowboy it, pull some stuff out *OFYOURASScough* and draw conclusions..."
Don't you just LOVE academic turf wars? The other group of hobbits in Indonesia are plagued with similar chest-pounding by people who are supposed to be intellectuals.
Comments 4
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
"Although we have not seen the material that Berger et al base their results on..."
So I guess we'll see. Their paper would have been peer reviewed, but if their concerns and objections are addressed well by Berger, then the ball's still very much in play.
Reply
Berger / failed to review existing documentation, much of it published by Nelson or Fitzpatrick
... remains unearthed by Fitzpatrick and Nelson / only miles from Berger's two sites.
... stepping outside his own area of expertise
... "You just can't walk in and cowboy it, pull some stuff out *OFYOURASScough* and draw conclusions..."
Helloooooo academic turf war!
FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT! FIGHT!
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment