Leave a comment

Comments 4

chibibluebird October 20 2008, 03:30:45 UTC
ending a line with "the" three times in a row
caused me to be distracted by it

i would really reconsider the frequency with which you end lines on unimportant words, i found it unduly distracting throughout

it's confusing how lillaree
a woman, is compared to a nameless man at the beginning. is that on purpose?

"they had to hold you back when she said that to you, and all they said in return was that
your mother was a lovely lady."
said in return suggests they said it in reply to the mother

the last two lines are a little generic. cut them?

i agree, good work.

Reply


somerled October 21 2008, 00:44:20 UTC
Also, I think you can start it more suddenly. "it's been almost three years." is a slow start. I'll offer a revision that plays with some of the meanings available in the opening:

Three years and your face
faded, blurred out like the nameless
off to prison

etc, etc.

Reply


thepassinator October 21 2008, 20:07:38 UTC
much thanks! i will take these into consideration when i do my edits!

<3passy

Reply


macdaill November 1 2008, 19:15:41 UTC
Powerfull themes and images, even the loose structure seems to work.

My advice is pretty standard, I think you can say it better with fewer words. Stronger verbs.

Well done.

Hang in there, never give up!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up