Livejournal
Log in
Post
Friends
My journal
themonkeycabal
in
who_daily
(no subject)
May 16, 2010 20:30
Amy's Choice Reaction Post II
Community Posts
diggerdydum
reactipoll
Reaction Posts
lannamichaels
with a
reaction post of squee
tardis_stowaway
gives it
a thumbs up
parrot_knight
says it was
"Generally a story which successfully reconciled the need to be straightforwardly entertaining with 'doing something different', but frustrating for those hoping for something more complex."
badwolf56
has
some thoughts on the episode
darknote
thought
it was pretty fantastic, despite a few big flaws
caz963
thinks
this was the best episode of the new series so far
x_erikah_x
lovd it
boji
is
not thrilled with Karen Gillian, and thought the episode could have been great rather than merely good
elisi
has some
thoughts on the episode
vonquixote
calls
this episode their favorite so far, and is very taken with Eleven
jinxed_wood
thought
it was brilliant
neohippie
thought
the episodes was weird, but likes it more on thinking about it
elenopa
has
some thoughts
eve11
with
some thoughts on rewatch
nycdeb
also
has some thoughts on rewatch
ladychi
has
mixed feelings about the episode
chinesebakery
adored it
andrastewhite
says
it felt slightly flat
selenak
says
this is the first non-Moffat episode of the season they're happy with
wheresmycow
loved it
honorh
calls it
a good hour of Who
Leave a comment
Previous post
Next post
Up