As the final Test of this Ashes series dies the death…

Aug 25, 2013 16:50

… a last bit of fandom critical analysis (I truly do loathe the term ‘meta’).

Can we make up our minds, please? )

writing, essays, ethics, fandom, britpicking, critical analysis

Leave a comment

Comments 9

shezan August 25 2013, 16:38:32 UTC
THIS.

...as they say in fannish circles.

Reply

Ta, love. wemyss August 25 2013, 18:54:44 UTC
I know, there's nowt queer as folk, but one really is baffled, sometimes....

Reply


steepholm August 25 2013, 16:38:35 UTC
I'm surprised - shocked, really - that you can tear yourself away from watching England chase down those runs, but everything you say here is to my mind unexceptionable. I do in fact believe that some groups are more privileged than others, but even if you think you're dealing with a privileged group, the respect (aka courtesy) due to all people demands that we err, if at all, on the side of Getting It Right, where it lies within our power to do so (and thanks to the internet, research has never been less onerous).

Reply

The key to multi-tasking in an Ashes summer... wemyss August 25 2013, 18:55:54 UTC
... is to write over lunch and post at tea or drinks intervals.

And, thank you.

Reply


tazlet August 25 2013, 21:17:26 UTC
So welcome to Foaming-At-The-Mouth where, as long as we're on the subject, I just finished Jenkin's biography of Churchill, can you recommend a better?

We’re glad we walked behind the man who smoked the big cigar
Tra-la-la-la, Tra-la-la, Tra-la-la-la-la
We follow the man whose master plan has carried us through the war
Tra-la-la-la, Tra-la-la, Tra-la-la-la-la
One whiff of the old Havana,
We follow him right to Fujiyama
Tra-la-la-la, Tra-la-la, Tra-la-la-la-la
We’re just in time to hear the man who smoked the big cigar…

Reply

Well, now you've wead Woy's work... wemyss August 26 2013, 13:46:48 UTC
... there's a brilliant Brief Life by Sir Jno Keegan, and there is Martin Gilbert.

Reply

Re: Well, now you've wead Woy's work... tazlet August 27 2013, 03:10:28 UTC
Yay! Go Keegan! Go Keegan! Much of "Mask of Command" is brilliant, and he's readable!

Reply


*nodding* froganon August 26 2013, 02:17:05 UTC
Something there about transposing our own "views" onto a group, culture, or milieu as if we are adapting it or stealing parts of it to our own purposes...or co-opting it which is something that in general I don't much care for ( ... )

Reply

In fact, worldbuilding. wemyss August 26 2013, 13:48:03 UTC
Quite so.

Thankee.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up