Leave a comment

Comments 16

illereyn August 17 2014, 13:27:40 UTC
Interesting thoughts!

Reply


dormiensa August 17 2014, 18:31:27 UTC
this is awesome! :D first of all, thanks for continuing your series--great to get a medical perspective! and secondly, thanks for articulating all of this--i fully subscribe to your viewpoint and have instinctively assumed it for a while. ;)

Reply


vaysh August 23 2014, 23:37:33 UTC
Fascinating stuff - especially the thought that Lucius' and Draco's remarks about the big Weasley family is born from jealousy. I am a bit hesitant, though, to generalise based on the Black Family Tree alone. This is one family only, an exceptional family, too.

Reply

wellingtongoose August 24 2014, 08:05:20 UTC
Hi, just wanted to clarify - what I am generalising about the Blacks?

Reply

vaysh August 24 2014, 12:35:43 UTC
Also to clarify - I love what you are doing here and much appreciate the thought you put into these essays. I simply think there is not enough data in the books to generalise about the wizarding world ( ... )

Reply

wellingtongoose August 24 2014, 17:10:46 UTC
I am confused by the idea that cancer, alzheimers and osteoarthritis are man-made diseases. There are definitely risk factors that increase the odds of people getting these diseases at an earlier than average point in time, however everyone, regardless of their lifestyle will get these diseases, if they live long enough. It is not a question of if but a question of when. The reason these disease are relatively rare in developing countries is that people tend to die of infectious diseases long before they would otherwise develop degenerative disease.

Reply


The Daily Snitch – Sunday Edition, 24 August 2014 livejournal August 24 2014, 15:17:35 UTC
User vaysh referenced to your post from The Daily Snitch - Sunday Edition, 24 August 2014 saying: [...] wrote an essay on The Missing Babies: Family Planning, Magical Style [...]

Reply


This is awesome anonymous August 24 2014, 17:08:53 UTC
HP meta- what a throwback. I saw you posted this on tumblr and got really excited. I love your meta in general and now it's related to HP!? Thanks for sharing!!!!!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up