Mel will probably disagree with me, but I found the Boone family in The Drowned Vault to be rather cliched and irritating. Nope, I agree with you on that one. They're from a character type I tend to like but they were cardboard-like (more so than in the previous book, I guess?) and thus meh. Drowned Vault had the same flaw as When the Stars threw Down their Spears: there was too much going on and too little concrete explanation for a lot of it.
*still needs to read a Brandon Sanderson book*
I read Clara's War too. It was riveting, though I wouldn't say it left me reeling... just often rather confused as to why certain characters were motivated. Fiction has left me expecting more clear cut 'whys' than she had to offer. :*>
Huh, really. I'm glad to know we share the same opinion on the matter. ;)) (...yeah, I think part of it was meeting the parents? I wasn't overly fond of them all in the first one, but it was worse in the second.) I can see that, though I liked Drowned Vault more than When the Stars Threw Down Their Spears; at least the former has more books to allow for further explanation!
Well, you'll have to let me know what you think when/if you read any of his books. :)
I suppose reeling in Clara's War had to do with just everything they went through, the courage shown, and then the remarkable ending. Heh, I guess all the non-fiction this year has paid off since I don't remember being that confused beyond just thinking that people were people
( ... )
(I don't remember the Boons doing much in the first book, except for cheering the main characters on in their difficult coursework... and maybe flying a plane. Which is funny, because I think I retained a better overall picture of Dragon's Tooth than Drowned Vault. But yeah, I do remember eyeing the book a little sideways when the Boone parental units showed up in DV. ;)) )
...I wonder if it's possible to queue books at the library so they'll show up in a certain month... because then I could order them while I'm thinking about it and not end up with eleventy-billion books all at once. :p
(They flew a plane and also trained Cyrus and Antigone some, I think; in general, though, they were the super-talented, super-pretty people with no flaws. Heh, yeah, it just got worse when Mr. and Mrs. Boone showed up. ;)) )
Ummm...I don't think so? But if you figure it out, let me know! I'd love to do that. ;)) (And it is a great idea, and should be doable because of that...)
Interestingly, I've had Clara's War on my Amazon wishlist for some time. :P
I need to be sure and read a McKillip this year - I didn't last year, and so my list was sadly lacking! That second cover you posted is indeed a standout.
I ought to read The Importance of Being Earnest, as well.
The N.D. Wilson quote is lovely and thoughtful - a few of my sisters read the 100 Cupboards series years ago, and it did sound creative, but for some reason I didn't quite like the sound of it... Can't recall what it was, now. But he did write Leepike Ridge, which I enjoyed. So, yet another series to add to the To Read list? The cover is wildly creepy, I must say.
Some of those non-fiction titles are positively awe-inspiring; Refrigeration in America? Brave, brave soul, to have picked that one up!
I shall try to get my whole questionnaire copied over from tumblr one of these days. /too rushed at this hour to properly italicize or underline book titles :P Sorry!
Comments 10
*still needs to read a Brandon Sanderson book*
I read Clara's War too. It was riveting, though I wouldn't say it left me reeling... just often rather confused as to why certain characters were motivated. Fiction has left me expecting more clear cut 'whys' than she had to offer. :*>
*happily scoops titles from the non-fic reading*
Reply
Well, you'll have to let me know what you think when/if you read any of his books. :)
I suppose reeling in Clara's War had to do with just everything they went through, the courage shown, and then the remarkable ending. Heh, I guess all the non-fiction this year has paid off since I don't remember being that confused beyond just thinking that people were people ( ... )
Reply
...I wonder if it's possible to queue books at the library so they'll show up in a certain month... because then I could order them while I'm thinking about it and not end up with eleventy-billion books all at once. :p
Reply
Ummm...I don't think so? But if you figure it out, let me know! I'd love to do that. ;)) (And it is a great idea, and should be doable because of that...)
Reply
Interestingly, I've had Clara's War on my Amazon wishlist for some time. :P
I need to be sure and read a McKillip this year - I didn't last year, and so my list was sadly lacking!
That second cover you posted is indeed a standout.
I ought to read The Importance of Being Earnest, as well.
The N.D. Wilson quote is lovely and thoughtful - a few of my sisters read the 100 Cupboards series years ago, and it did sound creative, but for some reason I didn't quite like the sound of it... Can't recall what it was, now. But he did write Leepike Ridge, which I enjoyed. So, yet another series to add to the To Read list? The cover is wildly creepy, I must say.
Some of those non-fiction titles are positively awe-inspiring; Refrigeration in America? Brave, brave soul, to have picked that one up!
I shall try to get my whole questionnaire copied over from tumblr one of these days.
/too rushed at this hour to properly italicize or underline book titles :P Sorry!
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment