Challenge #1 Rankings

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Notes

[01.] Please double check to confirm that I added up your points correctly.
[02.] Leave a comment here telling me if you joined my icon community, or if you've promoted the community (and a link), so that I may add the points in.
[03.] I will add in any points earned from promoting, joining my icon community, and signing up for making banners

Comments

[ksi_liv]

I joined your community )
By the way, I have a question: may I promote this community on my lj or this won't be counted?

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Excellent, I made a note of it and will update your points tonight.

Sure, you may promote your LJ on your lj and I will count it. Just send me a link to verify. Thanks! :)

[ksi_liv]

http://ksi-liv.livejournal.com/5153.html
here is the promotion)

[tonicangel]

I joined your icon community. I have to say, I love your layout! It's adorable.

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Thanks, I took note and will update your points tonight.

And I'm glad you like the layout! I have no idea if you meant this community or my icon community, though, lol. This community is lovely because of the code from minty_peach and the awesome fanart of loleia, whose artwork can be found here: http://loleia.deviantart.com. The layout from icon community is derived from code premade_ljs and the headers are made by me from Vanity Fair photoshoots (which can be found at their website) .

Edited: To fix mintypeach to minty_peach and added a link

[mysoulcries]

Hey i mentioned this place on my blog (:
sarahdoesdesign

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Excellent, thanks so much. :)

Your score has been updated in the ranking page.

[the_muffin_face]

youre icon makes me sqeak with gtiddy girldom

[navi_glow]

Hmm I think this is wrong... It's like cheating and it's a shame because you've obviously made such an effort with all the other rules.

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

I'm very interested in your opinion, but I'm afraid I need clarification. When you say "this is wrong", what exactly are you referring to?

The first round doesn't start until May, so there is still time to tweak the rules if the general consensus asks/agrees on certain issues.

[navi_glow]

Woops sorry for not being specific. I'm not very good at explaining my thoughts! It's just that I think points should only be given for icon-making skills and I suppose participation, and not for things like advertising which don't have anything to do with graphic design skills.

A lot of LIMS do this and I've never agreed with it...

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Lol, it's okay. Now I understand. I saw that you originally put this under the resource page and then here at the ranking page, and I was confused why listing resources or points might lead to someone being unhappy

[deepwonderment]

I joined the icon comm and am willing to be a banner maker for a round :)

[chefs_d_oeuvre]

Excellent! Your points are all updated and you are signed up as a banner maker for round 6 (I'll remind you of course)..