Constructive criticism is a difficult thing to do well, as we all know. You have to keep a good balance of three things: 1. the aspects of the icon that could be improved, 2. the ways in which the maker could improve them, and 3. the positive aspects of the icon as well. Below you will find a selection of votes from previous rounds from MVPs and ( Read more... )

( Read more... )

HOW TO: A CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM VOTING DECONSTRUCTION

This guide was created as a turbo_rumble initiative to offer examples of detailed constructive criticism.

Providing constructive criticism can become quite intimidating. Not only should you be validating your reasoning with solid observations, you should also consider how the icon could be improved ( Read more... )