Round 17 - Challenge 03 - Results

[absolutelybatty]

ROUND 17 - CHALLENGE 03 - RESULTS

Comments

[naginis]

Thank you for all the concrit! I agree with everything ahah.
I just have a question to the wonderful person who left the long concrit: there are no textures in this icon, so I'm not completely sure what you mean about the texture part? I just want to make sure I understand properly :) (you can pm me if you don't want to reveal yourself to everyone)

[jsfunction]

I didn't leave that vote but my guess is that the commenter thought the light on the left is a light texture!

[naginis]

Oh, that makes sense. :)

[jsfunction]

Congrats to the winners, and omg thank you so much! o.O I'm completely stunned that I did that well despite the fact that my ~creative idea~ doesn't seem to have come across that clearly - I thought the only way that icon could possibly get plus voted is if people like the interpretation :p (in case anyone is curious wtf it's all about and why those particular stock elements are there and what the text is: I was inspired by the Ganymede myth bc I needed something oooold for the theme, and because Dorian was another super extra beautiful guy so I thought, why not :D)

[nightbulbs]

Congrats to the winners! And thank you for the comments, they're always super helpful :)

[alisea_dream]

Wow, thank you. I'm so surprised because that is probably the icon I've made for the set that I like the less!
Also, the concrits have been so useful since the beginning, thank you all so much.

[shameless666]

Lol, I feel the same way about my icon :D And I absolutely love this icon of yours, idk if I'm allowed to say this, but I voted for it ♥

[angelamaria]

Thanks so much for the votes and comments and feedback you guys! :D And congrats to the winners! :D