You second constructive criticism vote would actually belong in our 'additional comments' section as you've mentioned nothing constructive to help the icon maker improve the icon in that comment. If you could please come back before voting for this challenge ends and submit a second constructive criticism vote by either a) choosing a new icon to comment on and moving your current second vote to the additional comments section or b) editing your current second comment to be constructive, that would be great.
Voting in the top 3, special category, and concrit sections should all be based around technical aspects.
Comments around whether or not an icon fits the theme can only appear in the 'additional comments' section. If you want to include a comment like 'I would have voted for this icon in my top 3 because I like x & x technical points, but I wasn't sure how you'd interpreted the theme for this challenge into your icon.' in the 'additional comments' section only that's fine.
I didn't catch you in time so you don't need to come back and edit your vote for this challenge, but keep in mind for future challenges: your concrit votes this time were not elaborated upon enough to pass our voting guidelines. You need to expand upon the "issue" you point out, explain why it's an issue and/or how to fix it. For example, in the first vote, you could have said, the texture/lighting to the left looks a little out of place, throwing off the balance of the composition. It distracts from the subject. That would have been an acceptable vote.
If you have any questions/need any help with the rest of your votes this round, just let me know!
Comments 12
Reply
You second constructive criticism vote would actually belong in our 'additional comments' section as you've mentioned nothing constructive to help the icon maker improve the icon in that comment. If you could please come back before voting for this challenge ends and submit a second constructive criticism vote by either a) choosing a new icon to comment on and moving your current second vote to the additional comments section or b) editing your current second comment to be constructive, that would be great.
Thank you!
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Comments around whether or not an icon fits the theme can only appear in the 'additional comments' section. If you want to include a comment like 'I would have voted for this icon in my top 3 because I like x & x technical points, but I wasn't sure how you'd interpreted the theme for this challenge into your icon.' in the 'additional comments' section only that's fine.
Reply
Reply
I didn't catch you in time so you don't need to come back and edit your vote for this challenge, but keep in mind for future challenges: your concrit votes this time were not elaborated upon enough to pass our voting guidelines. You need to expand upon the "issue" you point out, explain why it's an issue and/or how to fix it. For example, in the first vote, you could have said, the texture/lighting to the left looks a little out of place, throwing off the balance of the composition. It distracts from the subject. That would have been an acceptable vote.
If you have any questions/need any help with the rest of your votes this round, just let me know!
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment